j evans
Omono
Here are a couple more
I like how the bark is started to look on this tree.
I like how the bark is started to look on this tree.
Need some help on Elm
- Thread starter j evans
- Start date
j evans
Omono
Well six months later and here is what it looks like. Needs to be trimmed back but I was kind of wondering about the proportions. If this is the final size for the top of the tree do you feel that it is about the right size for the trunk? Any other comments or suggestions? Thanks.
aml1014
Masterpiece
IMO the current canopy size is exactly where I would want it to be for refinement if it where mine. You'll need to build some taper in the branching before you need to worry about that though.
Looking very good so far!
Aaron
Grant Hamby
Shohin
I just learned so much from this thread. Amazing progression, amazing advice. I love where this tree is headed!
Phillthy
Mame
Any updates on this tree?
j evans
Omono
Basically left as the last photo shows and stuck into the ground behind the garage. Currently under about 6 - 8" of snow with current temperature of 11 degrees. Most likely will not see again until the middle of February. Looking forward to checking the pot situation, trimming back a bit and letting grow for the year to thicken things up. Thanks for asking.
Jamie
Jamie
j evans
Omono
I got some ambition the other day and pulled this tree out of its winter bed.
Here it is straight out of bed with no primping:
I was disappointed with the root growth. I thought there would be more but this could have been due to the dense soil that I failed to replace last time I repotted.
After root trimming, repotting and some trimming. This is one of my favorite views of the tree.
Here is another
In you opinion should I remove the "L" root on the right side. It kind of bugs me.
Another view that I think is good
Any suggestions other than grow, cut, grow, cut, grow, cut and on and on? Thanks
Here it is straight out of bed with no primping:
I was disappointed with the root growth. I thought there would be more but this could have been due to the dense soil that I failed to replace last time I repotted.
After root trimming, repotting and some trimming. This is one of my favorite views of the tree.
Here is another
In you opinion should I remove the "L" root on the right side. It kind of bugs me.
Another view that I think is good
Any suggestions other than grow, cut, grow, cut, grow, cut and on and on? Thanks
Smoke
Ignore-Amus
Where is the wire and training?
Why two heavy apex?
Why is plant so shallow in pot? (Soil line should be about 1.5 inches higher)
About here\/
Why two heavy apex?
Why is plant so shallow in pot? (Soil line should be about 1.5 inches higher)
About here\/
Vin
Imperial Masterpiece
j evans
Omono
This tree has been at this depth ever since I have owned it. Never moved it up or down.
I thought that this pretty much followed the plan laid out earlier in the thread but guess I missed the mark.
Cut it back and start over?
I thought that this pretty much followed the plan laid out earlier in the thread but guess I missed the mark.
Cut it back and start over?
Smoke
Ignore-Amus
Bonsai is about improving as we move along. Nothing is carved in stone. Don't cut back anything. The top is great. Just lacks some artistic touches.
If you like it, thats all that matters. Everything here is a matter of differing opinions. Whether you or Evans lowers the tree has to be your moves....not mine.
Smoke
Ignore-Amus
Here is your very first concept drawing. It looks to me that the soil line should have been just about where I cut it off based on where you stopped your red lines on the base of the trunk.
j evans
Omono
Then, how can I make the corrections to include some artistic touches? I agree some branches are too straight.
Smoke
Ignore-Amus
OK, Pop Quiz
What is it you did in the drawing and did not execute into the actual tree?
What is it you did in the drawing and did not execute into the actual tree?
Vin
Imperial Masterpiece
The suspense is killing me! 
(I see it )
And the real kicker is it was there at some point.
(I see it )And the real kicker is it was there at some point.
j evans
Omono
I guess that is why you guys are experts and I am still trying to learn. I'd say that the lack of wiring has resulted in the tree not having enough movement in the newly formed branches. I had thought about that but was trying to use more the grow and clip method as I thought that I was going to have to build up branch thickness anyway. Other than that I am at a lack of seeing it.
j evans
Omono
Guess it is a good thing that its not a snake or I'd be toast.
Vin
Imperial Masterpiece
It's got the beginnings of a really nice tree.
j evans
Omono
Vin - should I try to pull that down or should I just cut it back to about I'd guess 3/8" where it starts to curl upward? What do I do about the straightness in all of the other branches, trim them back harder also? Any concern about the lack of root growth? Thanks for the help.
Smoke
Ignore-Amus
Remember the stick drawings I instructed a nit wit to do? Do that to the two pictures I posted and get back to me. The difference will be startling.
Similar threads
