Do these trees have potential? (Mugo pine, Birds nest spruce)

Cruiser

Chumono
Messages
637
Reaction score
1,343
Location
Thurston County Washington
USDA Zone
8a
I found a birds nest spruce and Mugo pine at a local nursery. The root masses were not potted, missing chunks, and were exposed for at least a year. Despite that, the foliage looks ok on both trees.

The spruce has 3 trunks each 3-5 in diameter. The Mugo trunk is 4 in.

Both trees were potted into large containers to help their roots recover. Id like to prune some branches on the spruce soon and work on the pine branches this summer.

I’ve been learning about bonsai styling but I’m still new to all this so I’m not quite sure what the best way to prune these trees is.

Could someone more experienced please provide some direction?
 

Attachments

  • 995A39FC-7C88-4CA2-A18A-6FA9D1709F2C.jpeg
    995A39FC-7C88-4CA2-A18A-6FA9D1709F2C.jpeg
    340.3 KB · Views: 307
  • C3A45FBA-6C13-4C41-8B39-35BEB70788D6.jpeg
    C3A45FBA-6C13-4C41-8B39-35BEB70788D6.jpeg
    350.7 KB · Views: 272
  • F6CB53B4-E6E5-4CC9-BB06-2D6CACC48399.jpeg
    F6CB53B4-E6E5-4CC9-BB06-2D6CACC48399.jpeg
    338.7 KB · Views: 264
  • CD07A0E8-8D98-48EF-A22A-5F4AB29E95D6.jpeg
    CD07A0E8-8D98-48EF-A22A-5F4AB29E95D6.jpeg
    302.9 KB · Views: 241
  • AE7C8FF5-86BB-452D-A7DD-9A9025487492.jpeg
    AE7C8FF5-86BB-452D-A7DD-9A9025487492.jpeg
    235.3 KB · Views: 252
  • 8C7B32E0-8606-42C6-9F5B-C39E955B8FE6.jpeg
    8C7B32E0-8606-42C6-9F5B-C39E955B8FE6.jpeg
    283.8 KB · Views: 240
  • 54522829-341E-47D8-B59F-18B9B2441C40.jpeg
    54522829-341E-47D8-B59F-18B9B2441C40.jpeg
    288.1 KB · Views: 293

Potawatomi13

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
6,168
Reaction score
4,403
Location
Eugene, OR
USDA Zone
8
Indeed yes. Perhaps number one best suggestion is keep healthy and alive until possible to contact local Bonsai club and meet with experienced member to get personal pointers moving forward. Trees seem to have very good potential and would be shame to kill them so PATIENCE most needed and is most hard skill to master for new Bonsai fans. Be aware most newcomers kill trees with impatience and excess of "attention" not needed nor desired by innocent tree.
 

edprocoat

Masterpiece
Messages
3,423
Reaction score
378
Location
Ohio/Florida
USDA Zone
6
Both make great Bonsai. I think you may still be able to find posts here from Vance Wood who is a master with the Mugho pine. I have had two very nice Bird's nest Spruce, they are very hardy and the new growth looks like little bright green flowers. This is not a good time to prune any conifer though due to sap flowing which will be like the tree bleeding to death. Prune these only when they are dormant late fall/winter. You will find with a Mugho Pine that usually the best part of the trunk is just below the surface of the soil, they tend to grow roots that encircle the trunk like a tourniquet which will make the trunk swell even thicker.
 

sorce

Nonsense Rascal
Messages
32,908
Reaction score
45,579
Location
Berwyn, Il
USDA Zone
6.2
Both make great Bonsai. I think you may still be able to find posts here from Vance Wood who is a master with the Mugho pine. I have had two very nice Bird's nest Spruce, they are very hardy and the new growth looks like little bright green flowers. This is not a good time to prune any conifer though due to sap flowing which will be like the tree bleeding to death. Prune these only when they are dormant late fall/winter. You will find with a Mugho Pine that usually the best part of the trunk is just below the surface of the soil, they tend to grow roots that encircle the trunk like a tourniquet which will make the trunk swell even thicker.

Hey man! Glad you're up!

Hope you're well!

Sorce
 

Cruiser

Chumono
Messages
637
Reaction score
1,343
Location
Thurston County Washington
USDA Zone
8a
Indeed yes. Perhaps number one best suggestion is keep healthy and alive until possible to contact local Bonsai club and meet with experienced member to get personal pointers moving forward. Trees seem to have very good potential and would be shame to kill them so PATIENCE most needed and is most hard skill to master for new Bonsai fans. Be aware most newcomers kill trees with impatience and excess of "attention" not needed nor desired by innocent tree.
Thanks. I needed to hear this. It’s true, I’m excited to learn and impatient, but I don’t want to hurt these trees, so I’ll wait.
 

Cruiser

Chumono
Messages
637
Reaction score
1,343
Location
Thurston County Washington
USDA Zone
8a
Both make great Bonsai. I think you may still be able to find posts here from Vance Wood who is a master with the Mugho pine. I have had two very nice Bird's nest Spruce, they are very hardy and the new growth looks like little bright green flowers. This is not a good time to prune any conifer though due to sap flowing which will be like the tree bleeding to death. Prune these only when they are dormant late fall/winter. You will find with a Mugho Pine that usually the best part of the trunk is just below the surface of the soil, they tend to grow roots that encircle the trunk like a tourniquet which will make the trunk swell even thicker.
Thanks for the advice. I thought Mugos were an exception and are ok to prune mid summer? Either way I’ll wait until someone local with more experience can have a look.
 

Orion_metalhead

Masterpiece
Messages
2,999
Reaction score
4,465
Location
Central NJ
USDA Zone
7a
Youre in Washington state, which means your trees should just be coming out of dormancy. Let grow through spring until summer pause at least until working them. I would prune back mid summer for the mugho and then fertilize heavily with a balanced fertilizer in late summer fall to promote backbudding. This will give you option next year to cut back to.

There is an excellent thread on mugho in the pines subforum with @Vance Wood's advice on mughos. They are a versatile hardy species.

The spruce I would treat like any spruce... after first flush of growth in early-mid may hardens off, you can prune back to the point just after the new growth's elongation to promote budding back on the branch. Fertilize as with the pine through late summer and fall.

Both species love lots of sunlight. Careful with your watering on the mugho. They like it on the drier side.
 

Cruiser

Chumono
Messages
637
Reaction score
1,343
Location
Thurston County Washington
USDA Zone
8a
Update:
Mugo.. last growing season (‘21) was rough. It lost a lot of needles. None of the candles produced new growth. The tree sort of gave up on growing and just tried to stay alive. I believe over watering was partially to blame.

Fast forward to now… the mugo actually is putting on new growth. Needles emerged from last years extended candles. New buds are popping out.
This must be the second year “creep” I’ve heard about… hopefully next year it will “leap”.
 

Attachments

  • 563DBABA-B123-48BB-8CB0-9F8480806913.jpeg
    563DBABA-B123-48BB-8CB0-9F8480806913.jpeg
    414.6 KB · Views: 144
  • DDD0DFF2-5EA1-42EC-A60F-4724BC70AC8F.jpeg
    DDD0DFF2-5EA1-42EC-A60F-4724BC70AC8F.jpeg
    201.9 KB · Views: 127
  • 8BC9B3DC-515C-41A0-963B-6A8C89B8B2A2.jpeg
    8BC9B3DC-515C-41A0-963B-6A8C89B8B2A2.jpeg
    231 KB · Views: 114
  • 9B50E64F-C5E4-4A7F-82AF-45E5CF9AC2BE.jpeg
    9B50E64F-C5E4-4A7F-82AF-45E5CF9AC2BE.jpeg
    182.4 KB · Views: 142

Cruiser

Chumono
Messages
637
Reaction score
1,343
Location
Thurston County Washington
USDA Zone
8a
Removed a main branch from interior cluster. There were/are too many branches originating in one area that are starting to fuse into a bulky mess. More need to be removed, but the tree is still recovering from last year so I was conservative.
 

Attachments

  • AE4038A7-5EEA-4155-AFED-8E0478952698.jpeg
    AE4038A7-5EEA-4155-AFED-8E0478952698.jpeg
    424 KB · Views: 147

0soyoung

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
7,496
Reaction score
12,832
Location
Anacortes, WA (AHS heat zone 1)
USDA Zone
8b
There were/are too many branches originating in one area that are starting to fuse into a bulky mess.
I dunno, odd things are usually interesting to me. But there is, indeed, too much going on right now.

You've got lots of curvy/curly branches that I find interesting. I am enthralled by that curly stuff above and a bit to the right of the base trunk, and thinking I'd like that to be the main theme. So, I would be getting rid of the straight ones, and ones with sharp, angular bends.
 

Cruiser

Chumono
Messages
637
Reaction score
1,343
Location
Thurston County Washington
USDA Zone
8a
Yes, I also like the piggly wiggly growth! The current plan is to keep that part and tilt the tree to create a cascade. The long branch on the left would be the bottom branch. Of course, plans change, and this tree is strange, so I’m still not sure where to take it. (Or let it take itself)
 

Potawatomi13

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
6,168
Reaction score
4,403
Location
Eugene, OR
USDA Zone
8
Yes. But one problem remains: No branching/foliage close in to trunk. Great trunks though;). Best of fortune.
 

Paradox

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
9,339
Reaction score
11,414
Location
Long Island, NY
USDA Zone
7a
Removed a main branch from interior cluster. There were/are too many branches originating in one area that are starting to fuse into a bulky mess. More need to be removed, but the tree is still recovering from last year so I was conservative.

Wise move. If these trees are still weak, you need to give them all the time they need to become strong and vigorous again. Since the are a bit more mature, this could take some time. I would feed them every couple of weeks until mid October then start preparing them for winter protection, whatever that means to you in your area.

I would see how they start off next season, but I would continue to feed next year every two weeks and just let them grow. You can take a few branches off next fall that you know wont make it into the final design. Evaluate again in spring 2024 and see how they do before you take additional steps.
 

Cruiser

Chumono
Messages
637
Reaction score
1,343
Location
Thurston County Washington
USDA Zone
8a
Inspiration for the birds nest spruce. Some Monterey cypresses have remarkably flat and dense foliage masses atop thick gnarled trunks.
 

Attachments

  • D24A3D92-168E-4D4F-BE3A-41FBAFEE3680.jpeg
    D24A3D92-168E-4D4F-BE3A-41FBAFEE3680.jpeg
    305.3 KB · Views: 96
  • 6D0BA6FD-CE39-439E-B9CC-DEDBFADB13D8.jpeg
    6D0BA6FD-CE39-439E-B9CC-DEDBFADB13D8.jpeg
    339.6 KB · Views: 103

Cruiser

Chumono
Messages
637
Reaction score
1,343
Location
Thurston County Washington
USDA Zone
8a
Re-potted the Mugo.

Just before repot.

1679516014839.jpeg

The original soil was sandy with a lot of clay. Upon purchase I added a mycorrhizae tablet and standard potting mix around the edges and top of the root mass. Nearly all the root growth from the last couple of years was in the added potting mix.

1679516274398.jpeg

The sandy clay core was dug out. Thick downward growing root stubs were removed in the process.

1679516733904.jpeg

The mycorrhizae tablet worked. There was a discreet colony in one place where the roots were noticeably better.

1679516987719.jpeg

The tree went into a slightly smaller pot of 100% pumice. Im treating it as collected material until it shows more signs of vigor.

1679517392250.jpeg
 
Messages
491
Reaction score
731
Location
SW Washington State
USDA Zone
8b
You have retained the small foliage circled in yellow which is good, but leaving all the long strong stuff will eventually weaken the part that I think is your bonsai.
If it were me, I'd feed the heck out of it, and when the new growth hardens off, chop all the long strong branches to the first or second set of green as indicated by the blue lines.
I can see a nice stocky semi cascade in there.

cruizer mugo mod.jpeg
 

Cruiser

Chumono
Messages
637
Reaction score
1,343
Location
Thurston County Washington
USDA Zone
8a
You have retained the small foliage circled in yellow which is good, but leaving all the long strong stuff will eventually weaken the part that I think is your bonsai.
If it were me, I'd feed the heck out of it, and when the new growth hardens off, chop all the long strong branches to the first or second set of green as indicated by the blue lines.
I can see a nice stocky semi cascade in there.

View attachment 478036
I fed it a lot the last couple of years but growth has been underwhelming. Two medium branches were removed in ‘21 and one last year. There wasn’t a noticeable response.
The tree just doesn’t seem strong enough to do any major removal at this point. Current years buds look so-so. My theory is that the poor soil conditions were a factor which is why I removed it and went with pumice.
 
Top Bottom