Oh, The Shame...

Messages
3,554
Reaction score
4,269
Have a customer, who had one of these "S" Curve Import Chinese Elms...

You know, the drill. The one's folks keep hidden away in the furthest most point of their benches, or even under their benches... away from prying eyes. For fear that they might be spotted and one would have try and quickly come up with some sort of a reasonable answer as to why it exists within their collection.
Perhaps it is just a friend's and you are holding it for them? Or, good ol' Grandma bought it for you at the nickel and dime store along with some shoots of bamboo sitting in decades old stale water?

Well, I am going to show you what to do with it, so never again would one have to feel the terrible wrath of the "Bonsai Shame"... You will never again not be able to invite others over for a Barbecue, and have to worry about burning the meat just to create enough smoke so that your guests have watery eyes and will not be able to see past the plumes of smoke to see what may lay beyond! We will not be slicing and dicing... no magical formula that needs wiping, even no worries about endless grinding to remove that troubled spot, No! And yet, this method is only guaranteed to work on the most terrible of trees... Have a tree that's not so bad, don't try it! Have a tree that makes you glad, put it away! This method is only for those that make you sad...

So, my customer, has a tree that he has let go because of not really know what or where to go with it to make it have even the slightest possibility of becoming a decent or good tree. I told him I did, so he said have at it... so I did...

First off, "S" Curve Chinese Elms naturally when let go, will want to weep. So they are the perfect candidate for a "Weeping Willow Style". Their leaves also will reduce very far down, so the scale of them plays the part. Lastly, if one has ever seen a really cool, and very old example of the growing in nature, next to the side of a body of water, they often will have some really nice movement to the trunk, and yes... dare I say it? Will resemble an "S" Curved Import. So, Bonus... Right? Finally a solution, that one cannot say, there is noting one can do with this type of material, to make it a nice tree... No more, don't bother wasting your time comments.

So, where to begin?

First off unless one has a very big piece of material, which is usually not the case... most have trunks in the neighborhood of around an inch... one needs to consider the height of where the overall design will end up at. If one examines Willows in nature, especially the really cool picturesque ones along side slow flowing rivers, or even ponds, they are usually not very tall trees... Somewhere in the 20 ft. range max? So, no need having a tall tree that does not suit the image. Also, what often happens with these imports is that they have had the bends put into the trunk, and then been allowed to just grow from there... So, one will often find a straight trunk... some bends, and then again a straight stovepipe trunk shooting up to form the apex. This stove pipe area needs to come off! Don't argue, just grab the saw and cut!

So, what I normally will do when designing a Weeping Willow style, is find a branch some where near the top of the curves that I can then bend up to make my continuation of the trunk. Since I want it to play the part of it being the continuation of the trunk... it should then be able to have some bend put into it, to continue the pattern of the curves below it. One last point, here... if one is using this branch now as a leader to form the continuation of the trunk, and to form the apex... make sure that when bending, that the top of the leader, or top of the tree, ends up coming around to the front, and forward. This gives the lean forward, that one is seeking of the apex of the tree in Bonsai.

Next... With Willows, the branches coming off of the tree, always go up first before then returning back down. So, try when wiring to get this detail right! Will greatly add to the authenticity as well as help establish character within the tree.

Maintenance and Future Development... Chinese Elms in a Weeping Willow Style are very easy to maintain. However, they will require some work and will require a lot of wiring. So, if you don't know how to wire very good, Great! Here is your chance to learn!

So let's assume that one has wire the secondary branches of the tree down. What I do, is then cut all of the finer branching coming off of the these branches, to the first pair of leaves... No leaves close in? Then cut about a quarter of an inch away from the secondary branch and leave a stub. New growth will pop from the base.

With this style where one wants new growth to grow and form is actually more at the ends of the main branches, before the bend up and then back down of the secondary branching. This will allow for allot more secondary branches hanging down to develop. With Weeping Willow Style, one does not really use branching beyond secondary... Now, I know some are like what? You don't use it? No... reason being that if the secondary branches all hang down, all we would need any finer branching off of these to do would be to hold foliage.

When one examines a Willow... Often the branches coming down don't really have finer branches off of them, but instead have just leaves... So, what one needs to do to help establish this is to routinely go through a couple of times a year and cut back all of the foliage on the secondary branching to the first set of leaves. Allow for the areas above on the main branches to grow, to form more secondary branching, and when they are long and strong enough, one adds wire and bends them down and into place.

Easy, Peasy... Here are some photos of the tree I did for the client and the work that I have described here, and it's involvement. Hopefully no one has to endure the "Shame" any further...
Thanks!


weep1.jpg

Original tree. Before starting.


weep2.jpg

Cut above curves, with original apex removed, as suggested.


weep3.jpg

Close up of the cut.


weep4.jpg

Wire applied and left back branch, bent up and around forward to form new continuation of trunk and apex. Branching on right wired and secondary branches bent down.


weep5.jpg

Finished image of first style.
 
Last edited:
Messages
3,554
Reaction score
4,269
Here are some more views from varying sides!
See... no more shame. We take the shame and poof! It's gone!
Now. one does not have to run in fear, and the tree can proudly be displayed on one's bench.


weep6a.jpg




weep7.jpg




weep8.jpg
 
Last edited:
Messages
3,554
Reaction score
4,269
Here is one that I did quite some time back... on a tree that I was either holding for a friend, or my Grandma gave to me...
Can't seem to remember which it was?

The tree is no longer in my possession... Has not been for a while now.
Would love to see it's progression. If one keeps growing and bending down new branching,
there is no reason why the canopy should not become so dense with branching you will not be able to see through to the other side. Just as willows do in Nature.
This whole tree was design off what actually made up just the first branch of the original tree.

weeping1.jpg




weeping2.jpg





weeping3.jpg
 

lieuz

Chumono
Messages
753
Reaction score
1,315
Location
Fairfax, Virginia
USDA Zone
7
wow!! this is really unique and beautiful! well done with this! This is the second time I think where I see trees get restyled in a very unique way.
 
Messages
3,554
Reaction score
4,269
wow!! this is really unique and beautiful! well done with this! This is the second time I think where I see trees get restyled in a very unique way.
Thanks for the reply and the comments!
Sometimes, one has to think out of the box, in order to be in the box. Now if these trees only had "Caliber" they might be something!
 

lieuz

Chumono
Messages
753
Reaction score
1,315
Location
Fairfax, Virginia
USDA Zone
7
There is a person on instagram I follow and I simply love his trees. He has these raft style trees that cascade off from a huge rock planting. Here is what I'm talking about. His name is Apisit Chuladecha, his Instagram handle is "Chuladecha" and I simply enjoy seeing his unique trees from time to time. Like yours!
12145420_905132182905266_538309266_n.jpg
 

M. Frary

Bonsai Godzilla
Messages
14,307
Reaction score
22,119
Location
Mio Michigan
USDA Zone
4
Darlene is going to freak when she sees these!
More good work with mallsai.
 
Messages
3,554
Reaction score
4,269
There is a person on instagram I follow and I simply love his trees. He has these raft style trees that cascade off from a huge rock planting. Here is what I'm talking about. His name is Apisit Chuladecha, his Instagram handle is "Chuladecha" and I simply enjoy seeing his unique trees from time to time. Like yours!
12145420_905132182905266_538309266_n.jpg
Thanks!
This is a very imaginative piece of work you posted. I an not familiar with the artist, so I will check them and their work out!

From a storytelling point of view I like the raft look of the tree and can understand the logic, behind a tree falling over. And the new growth growing up again returning to the sky. I think it has some areas where it could be improved upon, rather than the newer trunks shooting straight back up, I would rather see more of a gradual return, with more of a swooping curve. Also, when showing or taking pictures, I think I would want a big rock of the same coloration of the rock planting, and would want to lay it on top of the base of the trunk. So, as to give the illusion that this is what actually made the tree fall over, and firmed the raft style. With that said, I think the piece is awesome and makes one want to stop and look and try to comprehend what the story of the tree is!
Thanks for sharing!
 

M. Frary

Bonsai Godzilla
Messages
14,307
Reaction score
22,119
Location
Mio Michigan
USDA Zone
4
I an not familiar with the artist, so I will check them and their work out!

He posts these on IBC Stacy. Drops the hammer on the nursery trees all in one whack.
 

Robert E Holt

Shohin
Messages
303
Reaction score
200
Location
Huntsville, Al
USDA Zone
7b
Sawgrass, I think we are going to have to build a new box for you. Love the work and the sharing. Seeing several of the recent projects you have posted helps me, as a Newby, gain visusal perspective of not only the how but what can be done with trees.

Thanks for taking tthe time.
 

cockroach

Chumono
Messages
565
Reaction score
1,560
Location
Taichung, Taiwan
There is a person on instagram I follow and I simply love his trees. He has these raft style trees that cascade off from a huge rock planting. Here is what I'm talking about. His name is Apisit Chuladecha, his Instagram handle is "Chuladecha" and I simply enjoy seeing his unique trees from time to time. Like yours!
12145420_905132182905266_538309266_n.jpg
As always, great work saw.

The artist above is a member on ibc. Here is a link to the thread about the creation of the above tree. He too does wonders with average material.
http://ibonsaiclub.forumotion.com/t16730-forest-cascade-juniper-number-2
 

M. Frary

Bonsai Godzilla
Messages
14,307
Reaction score
22,119
Location
Mio Michigan
USDA Zone
4
Sawgrass, I think we are going to have to build a new box for you. Love the work and the sharing. Seeing several of the recent projects you have posted helps me, as a Newby, gain visusal perspective of not only the how but what can be done with trees.

Thanks for taking tthe time.

Stacy is badass!
 
Messages
3,554
Reaction score
4,269
Sawgrass, I think we are going to have to build a new box for you. Love the work and the sharing. Seeing several of the recent projects you have posted helps me, as a Newby, gain visusal perspective of not only the how but what can be done with trees.

Thanks for taking tthe time.
Glad to hear it, thanks for the reply!
 
Messages
3,554
Reaction score
4,269
Stacy is badass!
Careful there!!!
Let's not get ahead of ourselves!

The whole point of doing what I do is to get better!
The whole point of me posting, is in the hopes that others do the same.
As well as to just try and show how radically different one can change a piece of material.
 
Last edited:

music~maker

Shohin
Messages
392
Reaction score
704
Location
Boston, MA
USDA Zone
6b
Here are some more views from varying sides!
See... no more shame. We take the shame and poof! It's gone!
Now. one does not have to run in fear, and the tree can proudly be displayed on one's bench.


View attachment 85746




View attachment 85747




View attachment 85748
That's a clever way to deal with the S-style tree.

I got one last year to challenge myself to do something interesting with it. I got the least offensive one I could find from the local bonsai shop, one that I could at least imagine as a miniature tree with some work.

I have a couple ideas up my sleeve, but its got a few years of growing before it turns into something interesting. I should have some pretty good bones in about 3-5 years, I think.

Maybe a weeping willow style could speed up my path to acceptable tree. ;-) I'll definitely consider it the next time I look at it.
 

BethF

Mame
Messages
194
Reaction score
207
Location
Lexington SC
What an imaginative approach to making a good tree out of poor material. Very impressive. Thanks for posting this. It shows how adopting a different point of view about what you've got to work with can reap rewards.
 

wireme

Masterpiece
Messages
3,671
Reaction score
8,238
Location
Kootenays, British Columbia
USDA Zone
3
rather than the newer trunks shooting straight back up, I would rather see more of a gradual return, with more of a swooping curve.
No way man, I totally disagree there, fallen down conifers, often the tip will grow upwards in a swoop, maybe more often the tip slowly dies off while branches along the trunk take off, straight off the trunk. The angles he's using maybe the only way for that image to work well for me, I like it.
Check out this fallen larch if you can make it out. image.jpgimage.jpg This spruce I started is using the same premise, the branch behaving like a fallen tree, tip withering, branch along the branch taking off, has to be an acute angle, no swoop or it just doesn't work, like the super cool creation above that you guys are talking about. image.jpgI'd like to see your weepers have upper branches shortened and falling down into the canopy rather than down the outside to the bottom from the top.
 
Top Bottom