2021 seed division: bonsaidoorguy's maple forest.

Bonsaidoorguy

Shohin
Messages
491
Reaction score
1,447
Location
Seattle wa
USDA Zone
8b
20210410_141856.jpgWell my trays of seeds are sprouting nicely. I mixed up some red maple, green maple, and a few full moon that I came across. I'm pretty sure that they all look the same at this stage so I'm curious to see what the germination percentage is.20210410_141832.jpg
 

HorseloverFat

Squarepants with Conkers
Messages
11,356
Reaction score
16,220
Location
Northeast Wisconsin
USDA Zone
5a
View attachment 367218Well my trays of seeds are sprouting nicely. I mixed up some red maple, green maple, and a few full moon that I came across. I'm pretty sure that they all look the same at this stage so I'm curious to see what the germination percentage is.View attachment 367220
Looking good!!!

No matter how many seeds I sprout... seeing every individual plant grow... it’s OWN unique DNA displaying itself outward is SOOO exciting! It never gets old!

🤓

Almost all of my “helicopter collection” maples are “out”... and my “unique trays” that just went out recently are starting to “move”.. exciting times!!
 

Bonsaidoorguy

Shohin
Messages
491
Reaction score
1,447
Location
Seattle wa
USDA Zone
8b
Update on my seedlings. They are doing well. I'm thinking I may leave one tray as is and let it develop. The only drawbacks that I see are the density of the trees and the random heights. I'll separate the red from the other ones and separate by size next spring. I'm thinking a couple of slab plantings.20210529_094120.jpg
 

HorseloverFat

Squarepants with Conkers
Messages
11,356
Reaction score
16,220
Location
Northeast Wisconsin
USDA Zone
5a
Update on my seedlings. They are doing well. I'm thinking I may leave one tray as is and let it develop. The only drawbacks that I see are the density of the trees and the random heights. I'll separate the red from the other ones and separate by size next spring. I'm thinking a couple of slab plantings.View attachment 377615
Peanut butter and jealous.
 

LittleDingus

Omono
Messages
1,635
Reaction score
3,063
Location
Chicago, Illinois
USDA Zone
5
I'm thinking I may leave one tray as is and let it develop. The only drawbacks that I see are the density of the trees and the random heights. I'll separate the red from the other ones and separate by size next spring. I'm thinking a couple of slab plantings.

The natural competition will give you a natural set of different trunk thicknesses. These tridents were all planted at the same time and grown dense.

20210529_122419.jpg 20210529_122524.jpg

This will be season 3 for these guys and you can see how one trunk is already twice as thick as all the others. That can work to your favor for a forest :)

You'll also end up with less arrow straight trunks that way. the natural competition will cause some of them to lean and bend in natural ways. Generally nothing dramatic like wire can do...but they should form more interesting forest trunks: straight, but not TOO straight!

The problems I see are:

1) You almost certainly will lose some to competition. Hopefully not many, but very likely some :(
2) I'm not sure there's enough soil in there for robust growth of so many trees. That could be a plus by helping keep internodes short though.

If you do hold a tray back, it will be interesting to see the differences in development over a year!

These are looking great so far :D
 

Bonsaidoorguy

Shohin
Messages
491
Reaction score
1,447
Location
Seattle wa
USDA Zone
8b
The natural competition will give you a natural set of different trunk thicknesses. These tridents were all planted at the same time and grown dense.

View attachment 377634 View attachment 377633

This will be season 3 for these guys and you can see how one trunk is already twice as thick as all the others. That can work to your favor for a forest :)

You'll also end up with less arrow straight trunks that way. the natural competition will cause some of them to lean and bend in natural ways. Generally nothing dramatic like wire can do...but they should form more interesting forest trunks: straight, but not TOO straight!

The problems I see are:

1) You almost certainly will lose some to competition. Hopefully not many, but very likely some :(
2) I'm not sure there's enough soil in there for robust growth of so many trees. That could be a plus by helping keep internodes short though.

If you do hold a tray back, it will be interesting to see the differences in development over a year!

These are looking great so far :D
Definitely not the right quantity or quality of soil. By spring the roots should allow me to remove some soil yet keep them intact and get them into a little better soil for a longer term. I'll probably select the tray with fewer sprouts to leave whole. Might loose a few, but I think I have enough there for a little "survival of the fittest". 😁 Nice little forest you got going there.
 

LittleDingus

Omono
Messages
1,635
Reaction score
3,063
Location
Chicago, Illinois
USDA Zone
5
Definitely not the right quantity or quality of soil. By spring the roots should allow me to remove some soil yet keep them intact and get them into a little better soil for a longer term. I'll probably select the tray with fewer sprouts to leave whole. Might loose a few, but I think I have enough there for a little "survival of the fittest". 😁 Nice little forest you got going there.

Are those the cheap seed starter trays? Like the $2 ones with the ridges on the bottom? If so, you might think about slicing some strips out of the bottom and setting it on top of another tray full of soil and letting some roots escape? That would let the roots in the top tray continue to knit some while giving them more room to grow.

Then again, my experience with roots growing through plastic is that it can be a mess to get the plastic off when you're ready too! Also, maybe the trees knit too well and you have an issue cutting out the contour to the pot/slab they eventually go into/on.

I usually have the opposite issue. I tend to grow things deep and need to trim off a large portion of the bottom of the rootball to fit into bonsai pots. I know better...I do it all the time anyway :(

Nice little forest you got going there.

Thanks! It was planted with the intention of being a fused clump by retirement. Once it fell below 5 trunks (it has 4 now), I sorta lost interest in it. I now have a big leafed maple clump that will hopefully become what this was meant to be...but much larger :D
 

Bonsaidoorguy

Shohin
Messages
491
Reaction score
1,447
Location
Seattle wa
USDA Zone
8b
Are those the cheap seed starter trays? Like the $2 ones with the ridges on the bottom? If so, you might think about slicing some strips out of the bottom and setting it on top of another tray full of soil and letting some roots escape? That would let the roots in the top tray continue to knit some while giving them more room to grow.

Then again, my experience with roots growing through plastic is that it can be a mess to get the plastic off when you're ready too! Also, maybe the trees knit too well and you have an issue cutting out the contour to the pot/slab they eventually go into/on.

I usually have the opposite issue. I tend to grow things deep and need to trim off a large portion of the bottom of the rootball to fit into bonsai pots. I know better...I do it all the time anyway :(



Thanks! It was planted with the intention of being a fused clump by retirement. Once it fell below 5 trunks (it has 4 now), I sorta lost interest in it. I now have a big leafed maple clump that will hopefully become what this was meant to be...but much larger :D
They're just reused flats from flowers, cheap and flimsy but does the job. I've found that the seedlings do fine started in a shallow amount of soil. Keeps the roots shallow, although I don't know why I worry, I trim any tap root at first transplant anyway. I started a couple of maple clumps this year for last years starts. I used over ten in each to accommodate for die back. I used a zip tie below ground level so we'll see in the fall how it did. I love doing trays of maples. I've given away a couple of forests and a future clump style this spring. 👍 People love them.
 

Bonsaidoorguy

Shohin
Messages
491
Reaction score
1,447
Location
Seattle wa
USDA Zone
8b
Summer update. These things are growing like crazy. I'm still considering a forest just using a full tray.
20210730_181816.jpg
 

Bonsaidoorguy

Shohin
Messages
491
Reaction score
1,447
Location
Seattle wa
USDA Zone
8b
I decided to go ahead and use a full tray as My forest. I took the mass of trees and hosed the soil out. Then took it as one mass of roots and planted it up. Since they were started in a shallow amount of soil there were no big tap roots to trim. Trimmed the long ones and I'll let it flush out now. Come on spring.IMG_20220305_114617208_HDR~2.jpgIMG_20220305_111620669_HDR~2.jpg
 

LindaPat

Mame
Messages
131
Reaction score
117
Location
Philadelphia PA
USDA Zone
6b
Looking good!!!

No matter how many seeds I sprout... seeing every individual plant grow... it’s OWN unique DNA displaying itself outward is SOOO exciting! It never gets old!

🤓

Almost all of my “helicopter collection” maples are “out”... and my “unique trays” that just went out recently are starting to “move”.. exciting times!!
I love seeing seeds come up at their own particular time.
 

Bonsaidoorguy

Shohin
Messages
491
Reaction score
1,447
Location
Seattle wa
USDA Zone
8b
Spring update. Haven't had much of a spring around here, but lots of good growth. I need to get my snips and do some pruning. Haven't tried to count the number of trees yet, but at this density I don't think it matters. I'm sure I'll lose a few and I may add a few from the other tray in the back where there's some empty space. All in all not doing too bad.
IMG_20220514_133121811_HDR~2.jpg
 

Bonsaidoorguy

Shohin
Messages
491
Reaction score
1,447
Location
Seattle wa
USDA Zone
8b
So other than one pruning in the spring I've just let them go this year. It's looking like a pretty dence forest. Still haven't tried to count them yet. After the leaves drop I'll do a little pruning to shape. So far so good.IMG_20220827_190516525_HDR~2.jpgIMG_20220827_190502109_HDR~2.jpg
 

Bonsaidoorguy

Shohin
Messages
491
Reaction score
1,447
Location
Seattle wa
USDA Zone
8b
Chopped them back so I thought I'd post a couple of pictures. It's pretty dense with some fused trunks here and there. Overall I think it's a good start.IMG_20230212_120141809_HDR.jpgIMG_20230212_120056078_HDR~2.jpgIMG_20230212_120116549_HDR~2.jpg
 

Bonsaidoorguy

Shohin
Messages
491
Reaction score
1,447
Location
Seattle wa
USDA Zone
8b
Before and after a late summer trim. Hedge trim at that. I'll go in after leaf drop and clean it up a bit. It's looking good though even if it's looking like a small bush. I still haven't gotten a count on the trees, I only lost one this year so far. I think I can get it cleaned up by the end of the contest.
IMG_20230903_134430601_HDR~2.jpgIMG_20230903_135939767~2.jpgIMG_20230903_135916727~2.jpg
 
Top Bottom