JudyB
Queen of the Nuts
Each side but #1 has some good points. I like the movement in 2 but there are some large visible scars? Those will heal in time. 3 is nice but something about the base looks undercut from that side. 4 is good, but will need a slightly different planting angle to not feel off balance. Tip back to the left a bit, rework the branches to work with this side, and I'd probably choose that one. You'll have to grow the apex back toward being more over the trunk at some point. Elms are really good therapy, they always need some pruning! Hang in there.