I have a "Red Fox' that I layered, but it took a couple of seasons and the explant has been weak on its own roots. It seems to do fine during the growing season, but a branch will drop leaves early and then is verifiably dead the following spring. Per this trend, it will be dead this coming spring after 3 years on its own.
The mother tree is grafted onto standard standard katsura root stock and was a potted ball&burlap-ed field grown tree. I've been trying to 'clean up' the roots for the last two years. The varietal has been weakly growing and root growth has been weak. It will be left alone this next year, hoping it will gain some strength.
My net conclusion is that katsura are not the most vigorous root growers, certainly weak rooting, compared to maples but not quite as tender as a pine. One might say they don't like having their roots messed with, I suppose.
I have tried to root cuttings from root stock suckers to no avail. IOW, I suspect it might be classed as 'difficult to root'.
I put it in the ground 2 1/2 years ago as a seedling, I root pruned it at the time pretty hard. I dunno what the roots look like because i'll have to check when i dig it up, but after the first year i got really good growth on it. It has really thickened up the truck this year.
You are on the high end of the hardiness range, do you think that has anything to do with the air layers/roots? From reading, they are suppose to have shallow roots.
Hmmm...If they take 2 seasons to air-layer i dunno if it's worth it for how fast they grow.
So hardwood cuttings are just a waste of time.
I was going to check the roots this year and if i cut any off obviously i don't think air-layering after root pruning is a good idea. I'm just going to cut off the top anyways. Decisions...decisions!
I like the trees, and they grow fast here. I will just try the seeds again this year no matter what i do with the mother plant. I am not aware of anyone selling them in the area or i would buy some seedlings here.
The only success i've read about is softwood cuttings in summer, but i seem to have low success on softwood cuttings overall.
Thanks for the response.