Crassula Ovata Repotting, worth it?

cbrshadow23

Shohin
Messages
269
Reaction score
333
Location
Fremont, CA
I'm considering putting my Jade (Crassula Ovata) into a shallower pot. I live in Northern California in a place that gets lots of sun but we have a "wet season" in a few months where fog comes through and rain is more frequent. The area is very good for these trees - lots of my neighbors have them sitting in pots all year in their front yards, or planted in the ground.

I purchased this tree several months ago as a 6-foot tall overgrown monster. I chopped it down to this current trunk and put it in the biggest pot I could find. I thought I may have killed it, but now it's sprouting out lots of leaves/branches everywhere. The picture below is from a few weeks ago - now there's probably 2-3x as much foliage.

I have a general goal of making a bonsai from this plant. I guess the next steps are to let it grow these branches for a year or so, then prune/train it how I'd like it to look.
I'm afraid the current pot is so large that it will:
1) Slow down growth compared to slowly up-potting
2) Retain too much water since it's so deep. I used a mixture of 40% succulent soil, 40% lava, 20% perlite. I've also drilled extra drainage holes into the bottom of the pot

If I move it to a smaller pot I'll use 50% pumice 50% lava rock.
I have about 3-4 months of sunlight before the wet season comes, which lasts about 3 months.

What would you do?

P.S. I know Crassula is looked down upon, isn't best for bonsai, isn't everyone's favorite, has big leaves, etc. Assume this has already been discussed :)

Thanks,
Ryan

Here's a picture of it from a few weeks ago. The picture doesn't do the trunk justice since it's deeper than shown, and the can covers part of the trunk - it's about 8" diameter!

257415
 

leatherback

The Treedeemer
Messages
14,054
Reaction score
27,398
Location
Northern Germany
USDA Zone
7
Take a saw. Cut the bottom flat. Scrape out the soil between the first inch of roots. Let it sit on your bench for a day. Then pot it in a shallow pot.

Jade in the right climate will survive a reverse trunk chop.
 

cbrshadow23

Shohin
Messages
269
Reaction score
333
Location
Fremont, CA
Take a saw. Cut the bottom flat. Scrape out the soil between the first inch of roots. Let it sit on your bench for a day. Then pot it in a shallow pot.

Jade in the right climate will survive a reverse trunk chop.

Leatherback, I’m not clear on what you’re saying I should do, or what goal this would achieve. Can you give more detail please?
 

AlainK

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
5,394
Reaction score
9,490
Location
Orléans, France, Europe
USDA Zone
9A
Where you live, I'm sure it can be a great bonsai, especially if it flowers. The flowers are in the scale of the plant, I had a big one that flowered in December, Christmas stars on a tree 😮
 

cbrshadow23

Shohin
Messages
269
Reaction score
333
Location
Fremont, CA
It sounds like you're saying I should cut the trunk right at the base near the dirt, then replant the top portion as a cutting. This seems like it would just be a big setback rather than progress.
The current roots are very healthy and doing great. The tree is growing fast and throwing out new buds/leaves daily. I'm just worried about there being too much soil in such a large pot currently, which might slow growth compared to up-potting over time. Also we're coming into our rainy season so I'm a bit worried about sitting water.
It's possible that I'm overly concerned though, and none of these are necessary.
Did I misunderstand your instructions above?
 

leatherback

The Treedeemer
Messages
14,054
Reaction score
27,398
Location
Northern Germany
USDA Zone
7
I am saying that you can chop the roots on these as small as you would like and plant it in as shallow a container as you would like. As long as you make sure the cuts get a day or two to dry, it should be fine. These take pretty much any abuse you can give them.

Mins sits in a very shallow but wide container. Once well-rooted this makes the whole thing a lot more stable than a tall pot.
 

cbrshadow23

Shohin
Messages
269
Reaction score
333
Location
Fremont, CA
I am saying that you can chop the roots on these as small as you would like and plant it in as shallow a container as you would like. As long as you make sure the cuts get a day or two to dry, it should be fine. These take pretty much any abuse you can give them.

Mins sits in a very shallow but wide container. Once well-rooted this makes the whole thing a lot more stable than a tall pot.

That makes sense - thanks for the clarification. Won't a very shallow container slow growth considerably?
 

leatherback

The Treedeemer
Messages
14,054
Reaction score
27,398
Location
Northern Germany
USDA Zone
7
Won't a very shallow container slow growth considerably?
I am not convinced of that. For this species, I think getting just fertilizer, water and sun does it. I do not feel that container size does a lot. But someone will for sure tune in on this!
 
Top Bottom