Deciduous are harder than Conifers... discuss

Potawatomi13

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
6,168
Reaction score
4,403
Location
Eugene, OR
USDA Zone
8
Conifers/mostly pines much more peaceful to work with. Exception is busy busy Jap Black Pines. Not much fun/always needing busyness;).
 

markyscott

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
6,111
Reaction score
21,369
Location
Delaplane VA
USDA Zone
6B
what deciduous tree requires as extensive and detailed knowledge of techniques to get decent results as a JBP

I’d only point out that I’ve seen a great many conifers in the US that could quite likely be accepted to Kokufu. Many with less than 10 years of training after collection. I’ve seen precious few deciduous trees in the US for which I could say the same. I’ve seen close to zero posted on this site that I would consider out of development. Why? Well, although I don’t think it takes a huge amount of special skillls, I do think that many folks start refinement techniques too early and that sets their trees back. Many don’t know how to build branch structure on deciduous trees while others just don’t have the patience for it. I believe that the thing that separates truly excellent deciduous trees in Japan from what we have growing in the US is attention to detail. For me it is not difficult, but it is extremely hard.

Scott
 

Maros

Chumono
Messages
566
Reaction score
2,981
Location
Slovakia
I’d only point out that I’ve seen a great many conifers in the US that could quite likely be accepted to Kokufu. Many with less than 10 years of training after collection. I’ve seen precious few deciduous trees in the US for which I could say the same. I’ve seen close to zero posted on this site that I would consider out of development. Why? Well, although I don’t think it takes a huge amount of special skillls, I do think that many folks start refinement techniques too early and that sets their trees back. Many don’t know how to build branch structure on deciduous trees while others just don’t have the patience for it. I believe that the thing that separates truly excellent deciduous trees in Japan from what we have growing in the US is attention to detail. For me it is not difficult, but it is extremely hard.

Scott
It takes decades to develop good deciduous bonsai. One ( rarely if you are skilled and lucky) at least, two or more usually.
That's why you can't see them Now on the exhibitions. Not enough time passed on the West for developing them.
From my point of view, I do not know if deciduous bonsai is hader but it takes definitely longer.
 

Bonsai Beech

Seedling
Messages
5
Reaction score
3
Location
Ireland
Probably depends on where you are. Where I am, far away from most of you guys (I'm in Ireland), deciduous are possibly easier. Material easily found growing wild as well. I gather a few new specimens each year. But I do have evergreens as well. Haven't had many problems with either. Any problems I have had are usually down to me. Climate here means bugs and fungi are not a huge problem. Move to Ireland guys!
 

Brian Van Fleet

Pretty Fly for a Bonsai Guy
Messages
13,959
Reaction score
45,885
Location
B’ham, AL
USDA Zone
8A
D-trees definitely take longer to develop. For example, here are shots from 2008 and 2018. Evergreen trees can be show-ready pretty quickly with well-placed foliage. D-trees out of leaf are quite exposed.
Maple:
7031F218-5492-475B-8F92-81ED8A9ECCCB.jpegD3925115-B8DF-4EE4-88AC-196F93282FB8.jpeg
Hawthorn:
66C1C97D-55AC-474A-90BC-8C452B4726A8.jpegB8A5AB2F-FB4C-4BC4-923D-53ED6259A34F.jpeg
Black pine:
8A55CAB7-C5E5-404E-B848-6BC0DEF5AF29.jpegD45F4764-1EAA-4605-B1A8-F727DE7A4961.jpeg
Shimpaku, 2013 and 2017...just 4 years apart:
34B20C30-54BA-4894-9392-D913EBE04BA7.jpeg60D0724F-8912-444D-9DCC-EE6804FE9B80.jpeg
 

AlainK

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
5,394
Reaction score
9,485
Location
Orléans, France, Europe
USDA Zone
9A
A conifer can keep green needles/foliage for days, or even weeks sometimes if it's dead, long after you missed the first symptoms.

Deciduous recover better to various stress in my opinion.

Maybe a good excuse for my being so bad at keeping conifers alive? :rolleyes:
 

grouper52

Masterpiece
Messages
2,377
Reaction score
3,718
Location
Port Orchard, WA
USDA Zone
8
Well, there is apparently is an option of just doing while high.
How many pix are there of trees with beer or whisky, bottles, and pot threads? :p

Like the French poets and artists of old, I prefer the enhanced vision afforded by absinth to other stuff, both for conifers and the rest.

Conifers, BTW, IMHO, are much more trouble, but well worth it, and here in the tropics I both miss them at times, and and glad not to have to mess with them at other times. Overall, though, my best trees have definitely been conifers.
 

ABCarve

Masterpiece
Messages
2,676
Reaction score
11,452
Location
Girard, PA
USDA Zone
5a
Just got done posted this in my other thread and I saw this. No one has mentioned broad leafed evergreens. Laurus Noblis - Bay Laurel.
This will grow 60" per year in a big pot. 21013- 2018
 

Attachments

  • _MG_0806.JPG
    _MG_0806.JPG
    122.7 KB · Views: 28
  • IMG_3477.jpg
    IMG_3477.jpg
    250 KB · Views: 31

0soyoung

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
7,496
Reaction score
12,832
Location
Anacortes, WA (AHS heat zone 1)
USDA Zone
8b
Just got done posted this in my other thread and I saw this. No one has mentioned broad leafed evergreens. Laurus Noblis - Bay Laurel.
This will grow 60" per year in a big pot. 21013- 2018
To say nothing of what its leaves do for soups, stews, and jambalayas.
How often to you defoliate it?

Mmmm...m good tastin' tree you've got there AB' quite pretty too. :)
 

carino

Seedling
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Location
Central Texas
USDA Zone
8
A good deciduous tree is just as easy as an average conifer and a good conifer is more difficult that a good deciduous.
You make a very good point. Being new to this, it seems like a deciduous tree can be difficult or easy depending on the circumstances and the same holds true for the conifers.
 

ABCarve

Masterpiece
Messages
2,676
Reaction score
11,452
Location
Girard, PA
USDA Zone
5a
To say nothing of what its leaves do for soups, stews, and jambalayas.
How often to you defoliate it?
I'm glad you asked that question. I have never defoliated it. Not because I didn't want to. Please chime in if you have any insights. I had a guinea pig I tried it on partially and it didn't seem to respond. I do cut old ugly leaves off and the ones blocking light for new ones. I'm really doing this by the seat of my pants as there is very little info out there. Each consecutive year, since its been in a small pot, it seems to become a different animal.
How about Elaeangus, grows constantly, hard to kill. Rosemary, Illex.
 

BrianBay9

Masterpiece
Messages
2,752
Reaction score
5,369
Location
Fresno, CA
USDA Zone
9
It takes decades to develop good deciduous bonsai. One ( rarely if you are skilled and lucky) at least, two or more usually.
That's why you can't see them Now on the exhibitions. Not enough time passed on the West for developing them.
From my point of view, I do not know if deciduous bonsai is hader but it takes definitely longer.

Agreed. Couple that with the fact that few collected, deciduous trees provide anything to the final form other than the base and trunk. Collected conifers can provide a huge head start on the final tree.
 

0soyoung

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
7,496
Reaction score
12,832
Location
Anacortes, WA (AHS heat zone 1)
USDA Zone
8b
I'm glad you asked that question. I have never defoliated it. Not because I didn't want to. Please chime in if you have any insights. I had a guinea pig I tried it on partially and it didn't seem to respond. I do cut old ugly leaves off and the ones blocking light for new ones. I'm really doing this by the seat of my pants as there is very little info out there. Each consecutive year, since its been in a small pot, it seems to become a different animal.
How about Elaeangus, grows constantly, hard to kill. Rosemary, Illex.

I have no insight. Just a memory of passing on buying a bay laurel years ago and ruminating about bonsai of species with herbal uses. triggered by your post. You should start a thread about this bay. Its adaptation to bonsai culture is intriguing I need to revisit your thread on this tree.
 

ABCarve

Masterpiece
Messages
2,676
Reaction score
11,452
Location
Girard, PA
USDA Zone
5a

MACH5

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
6,064
Reaction score
28,362
Location
Northern New Jersey
For me it has been more or less easy to keep both conifers and deciduous alive and thriving with some exceptions. So horticulturally speaking both have been more or less the same for me. However, both are difficult to execute at a high artistic level. That benchmark might be different for everyone but I know what mine is. Although thus far I maintain a preference for deciduous species, I think both are fascinating in equal measure.

Wihtout a doubt, deciduous take a lot more time to develop correctly. That doesn't make them more or less challenging. Just a time frame issue.
 

M. Frary

Bonsai Godzilla
Messages
14,307
Reaction score
22,116
Location
Mio Michigan
USDA Zone
4
Decidious trees are harder because they fall under the hardwood category.
Conifers are in the softwood category.
 

Eric Group

Masterpiece
Messages
4,554
Reaction score
4,854
Location
Columbia, SC
I find the styling and care of deciduous to be more intuitive and easier than Pine. Also, their health is easily identified by their growth vs a pine or Juniper that can hide stress for weeks or months sometimes... so short term care and long term styling to me is easier... LENGHT of time it takes to produce a good looking tree when starting with mature stock though? No contest- Juniper and Pine can be made into a good tree much faster, especially Juniper! It takes years of work to develop a well ramified deciduous Bonsai, almost irregardless of the starting material’s quality, age size or species.
 
Top Bottom