Does this look stupid? Twin trunk live edge oval table top...

Japonicus

Omono
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Western West Virginia AHS heat zone 6
USDA Zone
6ab
It may be a tad tall ATM but I still need to level the 4 contact points more.
I'm not trying to match any particular project with the stand, just create one, my 1st.
This actually stems from a previous thread I began that was going to use a stump
but I never got the wood carving chain saw. That would look cool having live edge,
sap wood, and black walnut intermingling from the same stump or block of wood.

A few years ago I harvested some local black walnut and have made good on the corbels
for my new fireplace with it. I had this oddity of a 3 way crotch and for some reason failed
to care for it. I thought I'd make a short coffee table with this, but now I'm heading in the
direction of a bonsai stand. Left in the elements, I'm now forced to remove the bark as well
as some rotten sap wood.
Most of the sap wood is in tact quite healthily, though rustic with some worm holes.
DSC_2925.JPG DSC_2926.JPG DSC_2927.JPG DSC_2928.JPG DSC_2929.JPG DSC_2930.JPG DSC_2931.JPG DSC_2932.JPG DSC_2935.JPG
I removed the bark with a machete yesterday and began using what tools I had to get at the sap wood, but it's pretty hard.
By evening I decided to use a 1/2-3/4" wood chisel and hammer and still have a very long way to go with the crotch and legs.
I will stain the bark on the table only, and to cover up what once grew there, be it fungus or lichen, it will blend and all colour as one
on the live edge.

I've ordered some bits for the 1/8" Dremel but that's more what I would use for carving the actual bonsai or smaller stand.
Any thoughts on tools to remove the sap wood? I think the chisel has been most effective so far.
 

Japonicus

Omono
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Western West Virginia AHS heat zone 6
USDA Zone
6ab
I like each separately, but not both together.
I know, something about the oblong table top paired, goes more in a furniture direction, rather than for bonsai, ya think?
Do know that the legs are going to be dark warm brown walnut when I get past the sap wood, and considerably thinner.
Probably 1" thinner on the main trunk and more variable on the legs themselves. It will pop with oil based poly.
Water based makes the walnut more milky, and destroys the warmth.
 

TN_Jim

Omono
Messages
1,346
Reaction score
1,336
Location
Nashville TN
USDA Zone
7a
I really like this concept. It’s inventive and thought provoking. I too agree with BVF -maybe it’s that the base is so meaty..? Perhaps it could benefit from partial removal of some of the bark tapered down flush..?

Regardless, you’re on to something
 

Japonicus

Omono
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Western West Virginia AHS heat zone 6
USDA Zone
6ab
I really like this concept. It’s inventive and thought provoking. I too agree with BVF -maybe it’s that the base is so meaty..? Perhaps it could benefit from partial removal of some of the bark tapered down flush..?

Regardless, you’re on to something
Thanks Jim.
There is no bark on the base or legs. The sap wood remains and is being chiseled off. Will take a while.
 

Mike Hennigan

Chumono
Messages
906
Reaction score
1,349
Location
Ithaca, NY
USDA Zone
5b
Interesting pieces for sure. I think it would look better if you took the piece serving as the legs and flipped it upside down so the three prongs were attached to the bottom of the wood slab. It would look more cohesive and feel lighter and have more of an upward movement.

This could only work if you can anchor it to the ground somehow. I’m not sure if this is meant to be a semi permanent garden fixture or a display stand for shows. Could be interesting to play with that idea though.
 

Potawatomi13

Masterpiece
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2,030
Location
Eugene, OR
USDA Zone
8
Yup! Personally could see kicking/tripping over protruding root leg. Plan B?;)
 

TomB

Chumono
Messages
712
Reaction score
3,595
Location
S.E. UK
The top is a nice piece of wood. I would use it as a slab without the tripod/legs arrangement. You'll end up with a much better display piece that way. You could leave the bark, though I'd probably remove it and carve some texture into the edges.
You could always carve the 'legs' into a short root stand as a separate piece.
 

Japonicus

Omono
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Western West Virginia AHS heat zone 6
USDA Zone
6ab
Interesting pieces for sure. I think it would look better if you took the piece serving as the legs and flipped it upside down so the three prongs were attached to the bottom of the wood slab. It would look more cohesive and feel lighter and have more of an upward movement.

This could only work if you can anchor it to the ground somehow. I’m not sure if this is meant to be a semi permanent garden fixture or a display stand for shows. Could be interesting to play with that idea though.
Hi Mike, great idea!
DSC_2938.JPG
I tried that, and it accentuates what @TN_Jim said about it being so meaty.
The legs would need a short hour glass like figure to keep wide the contact points.
My wife prefers the original feet down stool like proposal. I'm working on it ;)
No this won't be an outdoor fixture, rather an indoor multi-purpose piece I think...
...if'n she takes to it. I figure she will, albeit too short for an indoor purpose I believe,
it will still be unique, and attractive.
 

Japonicus

Omono
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Western West Virginia AHS heat zone 6
USDA Zone
6ab
I love it. I think it looks best in it's original form.
I love rustic log furniture though.
Thanks. I appreciate all different thoughts and ideas. I've never done this before.

DSC_2947.JPG
Same tree, different slab, looks like a freek'n stool.
DSC_2942.JPG
The bottom side is presenting (my negligence in care mostly) quite the challenge.
This is obviously the contact points with the ground, not dirt, for the longest time.
Won't know till I get deeper how much rot is going to dictate how the carving goes,
but the picture in post 11 my last post, some of the heartwood is coming into focus on the tripod.
It's a different sense of pride using a hammer and chisel to explore. God I need a new chisel :eek:
But, there's a ball of burl here looking straight into the crotch upside down. There was virtually no sap wood
underneath here in several locations, and 1/2" thick right next to it. This is the challenge now.
DSC_1729.JPG DSC_2405.JPG DSC_2407.JPG
Here's what I'm talking about with water based (on the corbels) killing the warmth that the oil based (on the mantel) offers.
The mantel came from a 10' long local slab that was 27" wide at one end and 24" nominally.
I used the water based polyurethane on the corbels, because I thought it would help in the shadow of the mantle.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
SilverShoe99 Does anyone know what's wrong with this Benjamina? Tropicals 17
karen82 Does it have any chance (apple, I think) Collecting & importing 10
Colorado Josh Does anybody kiln fire their akadama? Soil and fertilizer (incl water and repotting) 11
matcha_bonsai Do you water foliage? Or does it slow down the growth rate?? General Discussion 90
D How does this look? New to Bonsai 3
R Does anyone know what this is? General Discussion 18
J Day of full sun does this look alright? New to Bonsai 6
J Just got a Parrots beak does everything look all right? New to Bonsai 3
J Just got a parrots beak. Does everything look alright? New to Bonsai 40
F Does anybody know why my bonsai has lost its leaves? Elms 8
Walter Pall this does not work Events, Exhibits & Outings 7
BonsaiSniper Does anybody have good places to buy bonsai stands for a relatively cheap price online or not? Stands 8
MavyBoy How does my first wiring jobs look? New to Bonsai 8
Wizeeerrrddd Does my field maple have root rot? Maples 13
Mike Corazzi How does scale travel? General Discussion 33
atlarsenal Does anyone else use Bougain? Soil and fertilizer (incl water and repotting) 3
Clicio Does Kanuma turn into dust? Soil and fertilizer (incl water and repotting) 8
A. Gorilla This Old House does Bonsai Miscellaneous / Other 8
theta Does this look like leaf spot disease? Maples 0
Japonicus Does everybody remove JWP flower buds? Pines 51
Mike Corazzi Does root position have any relation to tree sections? General Discussion 3
Flabonsai Which species of Trident maple does this look like? Maples 24
thellamattina Does this need to be repotted? Elms 3
Gene Deci Does it have a name? General Discussion 3
B Does it matter what kind of water is used in humidity tray? New to Bonsai 7
SU2 [FL] Does the "water before a cold evening" logic some (fruit or veggie) growers use apply to tropical bonsai? Tropicals 14
D what does 'container grown' mean? Maples 18
j evans Does a Quince plant need dormancy? General Discussion 4
zendroid How does one wire a tree into pot with little to no root 'flare'? New to Bonsai 14
Mike Hennigan “Standard” Japanese Quince, does it have potential? Fruiting 11
palagaban Does anyone here lives Norway? General Discussion 28
GailC Wisteria, does it have a chance? Other Deciduous 5
thumblessprimate1 Vitamin B 1 drenches? Who does it? General Discussion 8
Bananaman What does a $300.00 tree look like? Advanced topics 6
Bananaman So what does 300.00 material look like? Advanced topics 109
T What does true to parent mean? Grafting, layering & propagating 9
S Does Cut-and-Grow-and-Cut Work? New to Bonsai 4
grouper52 Grouper Does Flowers - Who Woulda Thunk it! Flowering 5
P .Does anyone know what’s living in my new/first bonsai? Should I be concerned? Anything I can do? New to Bonsai 16
WOOB Does Douglass Fur do well in New England ... New Jersey? Miscellaneous / Other 12
choppychoppy Does tree have to look like its natural counterpart? General Discussion 15
SU2 Does anyone have after-care advice for a collected Rosemary? General Discussion 30
Microscopic Does anyone know what this seedling is? New to Bonsai 49
SU2 Does anyone have ideas on how to process landscaping bark-mulch into smaller pieces for substrate? Soil and fertilizer (incl water and repotting) 20
MrWunderful Does Organic fertilizer burn freshly repotted bonsai Soil and fertilizer (incl water and repotting) 21
Gsquared Does ANYONE really like or appreciate the bitchiness on this site? General Discussion 647
Anthony Does this help you who use Oil meal seed cakes ? General Discussion 0
sparklemotion Journal of the American Bonsai Society - Does membership include archives? Books, magazines, and videos 1
BillsBayou Does anyone know of any woman who pulls yamadori from the muck? General Discussion 18
B Help. What does this mean? Junipers 4
Similar threads


















































Top Bottom