Fungus amungus

Messages
253
Likes
309
Location
Durham, NC
USDA Zone
7b?
#1
Hello
Is there a good fungal treatment for both pines and maples? They are the majority of my collection, and both are showing signs. I have copper and neem oil.
Thanks,
 
Messages
475
Likes
388
Location
Michigan
USDA Zone
6b
#12
This post has a bad underlying assumption: the multitudes of different remedies in the marketplace are not effective enough to warrant his use. The only way to surely cure an ailment is to diagnose it and treat it accordingly, all independent of how we wish the world would be. Keep your copper and Neem, just in case an ailment requires it. In the meantime, diagnose each new affliction and treat it with what is appropriate.
 
Messages
81
Likes
39
Location
Hartford area Connecticut USA
USDA Zone
6
#13
This post has a bad underlying assumption: the multitudes of different remedies in the marketplace are not effective enough to warrant his use. The only way to surely cure an ailment is to diagnose it and treat it accordingly, all independent of how we wish the world would be. Keep your copper and Neem, just in case an ailment requires it. In the meantime, diagnose each new affliction and treat it with what is appropriate.
So your recommending treatment of disease after pin point diognosis rather then Preventative treatment with a broad spectrum fungicide? That’s what I took from your post
You kind of lost me with how you worded your post but that’s like saying let’s put a stint in your heart once we know you have a collapsed artery rather then treatment with high blood pressure meds.
 
Last edited:
Messages
475
Likes
388
Location
Michigan
USDA Zone
6b
#14
Preventative treatment is left mostly to systemics. There are some, even lots of recurring problems that are sprayed for every season, like anthracnose on Cornus florida or I forget what Crab-apples get every year, and they need to be sprayed by mid June (here, in Detroit), but you don't spray the whole forest. But again, each problem is a separate problem, dealt with individually. You can use copper and neem in lots of situations, but individual species get different diseases and pests and there is no good shotgun approach.
 
Messages
81
Likes
39
Location
Hartford area Connecticut USA
USDA Zone
6
#15
Preventative treatment is left mostly to systemics. There are some, even lots of recurring problems that are sprayed for every season, like anthracnose on Cornus florida or I forget what Crab-apples get every year, and they need to be sprayed by mid June (here, in Detroit), but you don't spray the whole forest. But again, each problem is a separate problem, dealt with individually. You can use copper and neem in lots of situations, but individual species get different diseases and pests and there is no good shotgun approach.
Systemics are treatment not preventative.
 
Messages
81
Likes
39
Location
Hartford area Connecticut USA
USDA Zone
6
#17
They are precisely preventative, anticipatory, or proactive. They may not prevent want you want prevented, but that's different. Strategic verses tactical. Spraying is treatment.[/QUOTE

They have spray systemics so is it then a proactive treatment? I don’t know buddy... your confusing the hell out of me and I spray and apply pesticides and fungicides for a living
 
Messages
81
Likes
39
Location
Hartford area Connecticut USA
USDA Zone
6
#18
Is systemic is any fungicide or pesticide that is actually taken into the tree from foolishness back drench or roots. If it’s not a systemic it’s just a topical application that just kills the fungi on the cuticle of the leaf. That’s why I’m telling you systemics are a treatment and topical applications are preventative. Example of a topical treatment is copper soap. And clearys.is a systemic both can be sprayed clearys can be a granular application. It all depends on what the tree does what the application.
 

Similar threads

Top Bottom