How to care roots that are not doing well, in the wrong season to attempt anything


Reaction score
Turkey, Eastern Europe
Hello everyone.

The title pretty much explains the topic. How to apply proper care for the roots that are under stress when the timing is not right? Let's say that I have a pine and it has yellowing needles and I am sure of that the issue is with the roots. But it is not the right time to attempt anything in order not to make it worse. Or let's say that I have a maple with lots of leaves but it has some other root issues (root rot, disease etc.). I know it is not the right time (generally speaking, not for today) but if I don't do anything it will go worse. Waiting the right time to apply some techniques or solutions might bring the things in a more difficult situation to deal with. What steps should I take in this situation?

Thanks in advance.


Reaction score
Most of the times, problems can be fixed by adjusting your own techniques without digging around in the soil.
Yellow needles could very well mean you've been watering too much, or the pH is off, for instance. Disturbing the roots isn't going to fix that. Watering less will.

Adding insult to injury is a bad practice.

The most logical process is to first zone in on the issue and find out what causes it. Rule out all other possibilities after that.
Do this thoroughly, with great care and attention.
Then you'll find that it can most likely be fixed without disturbance, as with many plant related issues.
Then fix the issue.
Get it back to health.
Then think about what techniques to apply to a healthy tree.

Skip any part of that process, and you're deliberately putting your trees at risk.

Digging around in the soil, to what purpose? You can't find pH issues like that, and if you've been watering too much the foliage will tell you all you need to know.
Lets say you change the soil, but you continue watering too much and too often (root cause of the issue) then it's not going to do much good.

I've been helping gardeners for 10+ years now. Most issues can be brought back to them doing a little too much of something. Then the issue worsens because they love skipping diagnostics. It's a very human thing to do, but not in the plants best interest, although they mean well.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
J New Bonsai Owner seeking help to identify/care for injured plants New to Bonsai 3
AaronThomas BEHOLD!!! THE MYSTERY OF BONSAI CARE SOLVED... (you are welcome) General Discussion 18
H mugo pine care in hawaii General Discussion 11
M Post repot care General Discussion 12
V Care for bare root crabapple up on receiving question. General Discussion 3
Necrosis Yamadori care Collecting & importing 4
R Poisonous Pines and Care For Pines Pines 19
A My mom bought me an Azalea bonsai and i am not sure how to care for it. New to Bonsai 9
Atom#28 Bonsai Pot Care..... is that a thing? Pots 36
Schmikah Black Olive winter care? Fruiting 15
R Chinese Elm Indoor Winter Care New to Bonsai 1
Minas Juniper care after repotting New to Bonsai 16
leatherback Jabuticaba care? Tropicals 5
I Weird Insect - ID and care help Miscellaneous / Other 11
Nybonsai12 Multi-Color Satsuki Azalea Tips/care/info Flowering 5
EmptyLake I'm new to bonsai. ID and best care. New to Bonsai 11
F New to Bonsai - ID and best care? New to Bonsai 3
Cajunrider Japanese maple cuttings care New to Bonsai 15
The Seraph Seedling Care New to Bonsai 6
D Repotting after care New to Bonsai 23
SU2 [FL] Hoping for some answers&advice on *after-care* of swamp-collected Maple yamadori :) Maples 2
Littlejoe919 Pines in winter care? Pines 6
L Portulacaira Afra General Care Miscellaneous / Other 6
jasonpg Boxwood Winter Care General Discussion 8
J Juniperus nana winter care Junipers 16
ManSkirtBrew Azalea and rhododendron care and pruning questions Flowering 33
John in Toledo ID and care for a new pre-bonsai General Discussion 8
SU2 Does anyone have after-care advice for a collected Rosemary? General Discussion 30
R Care and styling advice for my ito New to Bonsai 20
Cofga Winter care for bonsai General Discussion 12
SU2 Just collected my first Bald Cypress, in need of some advice on potting & after-care General Discussion 35
coachspinks Kingsville/Harlandi Boxwood winter care Miscellaneous / Other 5
Gary McCarthy winter care for tropicals Tropicals 18
Adam2 New to bonsai care, and I need a little help New to Bonsai 10
Gene Deci Health Care Run Amok General Discussion 13
Phillthy Black pine after care General Discussion 31
Jordon Bigelow Tree Seed Care New to Bonsai 0
S I.D. my tree and help me care for it! New to Bonsai 11
Mudd31415 What care is needed to keep it alive? Junipers 5
Mellow Mullet The I Don't Care if Bonsai is Art, I Just Like the Trees Tread General Discussion 137
ajm55555 Deshojo JM Care Maples 14
SU2 Just potted my 1st large yamadori, am hoping for advice on its care! General Discussion 0
T JBP Trunk Thickening & sacrifice branch care Pines 11
J Northwest Natives Care? Other Conifers 6
Z Bougainvillea Trunk Size - Winter Care Flowering 19
Z Benjamina Ficus Winter Care - Potential Forest? Tropicals 8
Microscopic How would you care for this weak Hinoki? Other Conifers 24
Spdyracer Care for a stressed juniper from shipping General Discussion 32
T Bonsai care and coloring. New to Bonsai 21
L Sequoia care in southeast US Other Conifers 52
Similar threads

Top Bottom