It’s a cutting I have had growing in the ground for two years. It has no distinguishing characteristics.I’m unfamiliar with Gingko, but @Brian Van Fleet and @MACH5 both having stunning specimen. They may be able to help. A picture of yours may help though?
Yes. And they will.Would I do this by cutting down to a stump and hoping for several leaders to grow out of the base?
I think at this point time would be your best friend. You don’t want to chop too early. Strong top growth foliage will push root growth and in turn push top growth and girth.It’s a cutting I have had growing in the ground for two years. It has no distinguishing characteristics.
Why not?Chopping during growing period would be ideal...not when it's heading into dormancy.
I've read ones have done it in spring...and summer. Never heading into their dormant period. My tree is changing to fall color. Which means it will be going dormant soon. How can a tree recover a heavy chop being dormant?Why not?
It works well with many species (e.g., zelkova, ulmus, pyracantha) but not so well with acer palmatum because of its low phloem pressure.
If I wanted to have a tree with a finished height of around 24”, how thick should the base be when I do this low chop?Yes. And they will.
About 4 inches. How about 3 and reset your aims for something a bit shorter, like about 18 inches tall. Of course, it 1:6 is not a hard and fast rule, just a guideline proportion. Larger ratios of trunk base thickness : height go with feminine images. Far more with literati. Less with masculine and far lower with sumo.If I wanted to have a tree with a finished height of around 24”, how thick should the base be when I do this low chop?
Well, it really depends on how big of a base you want. This one was chopped pretty low after it had gained some size, and it stooled up from there.If I wanted to have a tree with a finished height of around 24”, how thick should the base be when I do this low chop?
About 4 inches. How about 3 and reset your aims for something a bit shorter, like about 18 inches tall. Of course, it 1:6 is not a hard and fast rule, just a guideline proportion. Larger ratios of trunk base thickness : height go with feminine images. Far more with literati. Less with masculine and far lower with sumo.[/
Do you think that this trees base is somewhere between 4 and 6 inches?Well, it really depends on how big of a base you want. This one was chopped pretty low after it had gained some size, and it stooled up from there.
View attachment 215275
I haven’t seen your tree, but if it’s in the ground, let it grow for a few years, then chop it down to about 1” above the soil, in the spring, then let new trunks grow until they’re about the thickness you want, then dig it up and put branches on it. 10 year project.
Do you think that this trees base is somewhere between 4”-6”?Well, it really depends on how big of a base you want. This one was chopped pretty low after it had gained some size, and it stooled up from there.
View attachment 215275
I haven’t seen your tree, but if it’s in the ground, let it grow for a few years, then chop it down to about 1” above the soil, in the spring, then let new trunks grow until they’re about the thickness you want, then dig it up and put branches on it. 10 year project.
No idea. If this tree is at the National Bonsai & Penjing museum, @rockm may know.Do you think that this trees base is somewhere between 4”-6”?
Ridley
I would have thought the 1:6 Rule would not apply to multiple leader tree like this, but I guess it does. I think I’ll (try to) wait until it gets closer to 4”, as I think the tree needs the extra height to look right with the relatively large ginkgo leaves.About 4 inches. How about 3 and reset your aims for something a bit shorter, like about 18 inches tall. Of course, it 1:6 is not a hard and fast rule, just a guideline proportion. Larger ratios of trunk base thickness : height go with feminine images. Far more with literati. Less with masculine and far lower with sumo.
Roughly, the same rule can apply to multiple trunked clumps. You have to think of the multiple trunks as a single trunk in some ways. They have to have the same visual "mass" that a single trunk would to keep the clump from looking weak and spindly.I would have thought the 1:6 Rule would not apply to multiple leader tree like this, but I guess it does. I think I’ll (try to) wait until it gets closer to 4”, as I think the tree needs the extra height to look right with the relatively large ginkgo leaves.