If you could collect just one of these?

Messages
850
Likes
2,100
Location
Northern Michigan
USDA Zone
5
#1
I was scouting a new area yesterday. A nice old lady with a 6 generation farm. The combination of a cow field and a bog. Not something I’ve seen before around here. Anyway, there are pics of 4 White Cedar. If you could only collect one which would you? Or none? 2A266CBF-0EE2-46FD-BED4-9F83C968A32F.jpeg 6C0C7661-8583-4C2F-8A94-B8F03DB7C3DC.jpeg 73E24A9D-B0FB-416B-9A56-F797A98ADBA4.jpeg F996FA49-38E3-41FC-92C7-C0164B3FD02A.jpeg
 
Messages
850
Likes
2,100
Location
Northern Michigan
USDA Zone
5
#11
interesting everyone thank you for the responses. I like them all but my choice would be #3 as well as @Maloghurst @Hartinez and @Dav4

# 3 has the biggest base at around 10'' and has a trailing root that really widens the base for good taper hard to see in photo. I think I may just collect this one. I like #2 but less going on with the main trunk.
 

Bonsai Nut

Nuttier than your average Nut
Messages
8,074
Likes
13,135
Location
OC, CA
USDA Zone
10A
#13
It all depends on the surface roots and the base of the trunk. Take some more photos showing where the trunks meet the soil, and see if you can reveal the surface roots. Without knowing this, the upper trunk is irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
Messages
291
Likes
438
Location
Montréal
USDA Zone
5/6
#17
I’d kill to collect any of those, amazing material. Good, gnarly thuya are hard to find here.

I think 2 and 3 seem like the less complicated projects, bonsai-wise, in my rookie opinion.
 
Messages
850
Likes
2,100
Location
Northern Michigan
USDA Zone
5
#19
interesting that no one picked 4. I like the tree in person but I am afraid it is already too close to death in the field and would not survive collection. It is a bit hard to play this game though without seeing in person.
 

Dav4

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
9,935
Likes
16,518
Location
North Georgia/lived in MA until 2009
USDA Zone
7b
#20
interesting that no one picked 4. I like the tree in person but I am afraid it is already too close to death in the field and would not survive collection. It is a bit hard to play this game though without seeing in person.
That's actually what I got from your picture... great deadwood trunk but appears very unhealthy.
 

Similar threads

Top Bottom