Josh88
Shohin
My top pick would be 3, then 2, 1, and 4 looks like it has very little to work with and not as healthy as the others.
If you could collect just one of these?
- Thread starter mattspinniken
- Start date
Mike Hennigan
Chumono
I second this. It’s hard to tell but the second one doesn’t seem to have much interest down low.
n8
Shohin
#3
WNC Bonsai
Omono
I like #2 best, but I am a sucker for leaning trees.
M. Frary
Bonsai Godzilla
Dig 'em all out.
Nicholas Box
Mame
#3
mattspinniken
Omono
I would but this lady said she only wanted me to take 2. I figured one this spring and one in fall. I want to scout the rest of the area before I decide on the second one.
mattspinniken
Omono
And....5 hours of work later. Thanks to the father in law for help.
Mike Hennigan
Chumono
Yo you made the right choice, that thing is seriously badass!!!
BobbyLane
Imperial Masterpiece
wow, impressive piece
SniffingKrylon
Shohin
I underestimated you, Three, and for that I apologize. Lol really nice tree, man.
mattspinniken
Omono
Haha! Nice ??
Hartinez
Masterpiece
Niiiccceee. Beautiful specimen.
Dav4
Drop Branch Murphy
- Messages
- 13,111
- Reaction score
- 30,187
- USDA Zone
- 6a
Great tree!
Mike Corazzi
Masterpiece
Ali Raza
Shohin
# 3
Potawatomi13
Imperial Masterpiece
Best choice. Looks even better out of grass. Father in law looks like Bonsai guy. Hope it does great.
. Father in law looks like Bonsai guy. Hope it does great.
Gene Deci
Shohin
Hey Matt, you need to make this tree a long running post as you bring out the best of it over the years.
mattspinniken
Omono
good idea, I think I will. If it comes along quickly and I got enough viable roots my guess is it will develop quickly.
mattspinniken
Omono
I thought I should update this thread with the unfortunately reality of collecting. I think this will be worthwile for others so I will post about why I think this tree died after collection. The one that died is the one from this thread not the one pictured below. I just put that here to help me feel better about life...haha.
When I collected this tree I had high hopes as I always do when I collect something. I have heard others describe the muck that comes with a tree out of a bog as "black death" well truer words have never been spoken. The other reason I believed this died is the tree had very little foliage before collection, a tree needs foliage to regenerate roots and this one did not have enough.
I can't stress enough how important it is to get the black death out when collecting Thuja from bogs. These are not pines and do not need the field soil to come with. Now when I collect any cedar I submerge the entire root ball in water for 1 day and then thouroughly hose the roots out to get the black stuff OUT! Also, I skip trees that have too little foliage. Be careful not to prune too much foliage off of a collected Thuja at collection or during recovery. I have seen trees with a ton of foliage and very very little roots collected totally fill up the collection box with roots in less than one whole growing season.
I have collected two others from this same bog and both are happy now but I washed the roots well. Thankfully this tree was not my personal favorite that I collected this year (see below for that) but it was definietly one I planned to keep for decades.
Anyway, some hard won learning lessons I thought maybe others could benefit from....
When I collected this tree I had high hopes as I always do when I collect something. I have heard others describe the muck that comes with a tree out of a bog as "black death" well truer words have never been spoken. The other reason I believed this died is the tree had very little foliage before collection, a tree needs foliage to regenerate roots and this one did not have enough.
I can't stress enough how important it is to get the black death out when collecting Thuja from bogs. These are not pines and do not need the field soil to come with. Now when I collect any cedar I submerge the entire root ball in water for 1 day and then thouroughly hose the roots out to get the black stuff OUT! Also, I skip trees that have too little foliage. Be careful not to prune too much foliage off of a collected Thuja at collection or during recovery. I have seen trees with a ton of foliage and very very little roots collected totally fill up the collection box with roots in less than one whole growing season.
I have collected two others from this same bog and both are happy now but I washed the roots well. Thankfully this tree was not my personal favorite that I collected this year (see below for that) but it was definietly one I planned to keep for decades.
Anyway, some hard won learning lessons I thought maybe others could benefit from....
Last edited:
