Kavanaugh confirmation

Status
Not open for further replies.

MHBonsai

Chumono
Messages
679
Reaction score
2,093
Location
Nashville, TN
USDA Zone
7a
I can't say I'm satisfied with the behavior of either party right now, regardless of political affiliation.

I keep asking myself...is Kavanaugh really the absolute best the USA has to offer?

I mean I feel for the guy, his life is totally flipped upside down here. I won't pretend to judge of if it is deserved or not. But how is the USA unable to find an upstanding citizen that both parties can agree is worthy of sitting in the chair for a lifetime. Kavanaugh ain't it.
 

substratum

Shohin
Messages
342
Reaction score
368
Location
Red Hills/Florida Big Bend
USDA Zone
8b
Not all of the posters here are from the USA.

All I remember is democrats = left. Republicans = right. Pretty much like Homer:
View attachment 212113
In all fairness, the political terms "Left" and "Right" are not readily transferable between South America, Asia, Europe, and the USA, which makes it very confusing for people following U.S. politics from abroad.

For example, by most measures, the classic and (justifiably) most vilified "right-wing" political party in modern history is the Nazi Party of 20th Century Germany, which was fascist, exercised tight-fisted centralized government control, were socialists, and rejected individual rights in favor of the good of the whole (Motherland).

Yet, the most right-wing faction of American politics, today, are Libertarians, which are a faction of the Republican Party, and are the closest thing to Classic Thomas Jefferson-style/18th Century "Liberals". Libertarians generally want to trim Federal government control to the bone, return power to the States, champion individual rights (above the government), want to legalize/end restrictions on just about everything related to person freedom (drugs, marriage, guns, etc.), and support free-market principles with very little government interference. Hardly what folks in other parts of the world would call right-wing.
 

substratum

Shohin
Messages
342
Reaction score
368
Location
Red Hills/Florida Big Bend
USDA Zone
8b
I can't say I'm satisfied with the behavior of either party right now, regardless of political affiliation.

I keep asking myself...is Kavanaugh really the absolute best the USA has to offer?

I mean I feel for the guy, his life is totally flipped upside down here. I won't pretend to judge of if it is deserved or not. But how is the USA unable to find an upstanding citizen that both parties can agree is worthy of sitting in the chair for a lifetime. Kavanaugh ain't it.
Up until the Democrats unloaded their unsubstantiated, straight-face lies upon the man, he was among the top-five most respected Federal Appellate Court Judges in the land. Given that none of what is being propagated can be substantiated, nothing should have changed.

Here's a little humor piece a friend of mine (Chuck Porretto) wrote to characterize what has occurred. IMHO, it's just about this sleazy, too:

Dems..... Mr. Kavamaugh, When did you first become aware that someone accused you of being an accomplice of Ted Bundy when you were 8 years old?
Judge Kavanaugh.... Well, I'm, I was not an accomplice of Ted Bundy.
Dems...... Stop with the word games, and tell us when you first heard the accusation ...
Judge Kavanaugh.... Well I'm, I guess it was Tuesday.
Dems.... Ah hah. Well we know that It was not Tuesday. You heard about it on Monday. You are not fit to be on the Supreme Court, and your lies means that most likely you were in fact an accomplice of Ted Bundy.
Judge Kavanaugh.... No way. This is an outrage. I will fight to protect my good name...
Dems... Oh dear, your temperament is disgualifying.
Dems.... Did you throw ice in college?
Judge Kavanaugh... Well let me explain
Dems... Are you aware that ice is the cause of the Titanic sinking?
Judge Kavanaugh.... This is crazy...
Dems.... How dare you call me crazy... Do you call all women crazy?
NEWS UPDATE...... This is Rachel Madow..... Judge Kavanaugh calls all women Crazy.....
Dems..... Mr. Kavanaugh; Are you anti Science?
Judge Kavanaugh..... No, I beli....
Dems.... Stop taking so long to answer.... So are you aware of and recognize Einstien' s theory of relativity?
Judge Kavanaugh... Yes, I studied about....
Dems... That's quite enough..... So you do accept the fact that time travel is possible?
Judge Kavanaugh.... Well. I..... I...
Dems.... Are you aware that you have been accused of traveling back in time, and are in fact the architect of Hitler's Final Solution?
Judge Kavanaugh... That is preposterous....
Dems.... Why are you so belligerent. Your temperament is very disconcerting..... Now tell us.... Do you black out before or after you murder Train loads of Jews?
Judge Kavanaugh... I do not black out.
Dems... Stop lying, We have an anonymous tip from a young woman who was at Auschwitz that says other wise... Do you black out before or after your murderous sprees?
Judge Kavanaugh.... I do not ...
Dems.... OMG answer this... Did you sleep last night.
Judge Kavanaugh... Um yes..
Dems... And we're you unconscience when you are sleeping?
Judge Kavanaugh.... Um I guess so...
Dems... Now pay attention Jew Killer; When people black out, are they unconscience?
Judge Kavanaugh.... Well I guess yes....
Dems.... ah ha.... So you admit that people that black out are unconscience, and you also admit that you were unconscience just last night. I think the American people are smart enough to see through your lies and obfuscation.
Judge Kavanaugh.... This is preposterous....
Dems.... Stop with the anger Judge, It is very unbecoming. Now Tell us... Exactly how many dirty Jews did you murder?
Judge Kavanaugh.... ARRRRGHH. I did not murder any dirty Jews....
NEWS ALERT..... This is Anderson Cooper, Judge Kavanaugh just went on an anti Semetic tirade, and Called all Jewish Americans dirty Jews.
 

barrosinc

Masterpiece
Messages
4,127
Reaction score
4,691
Location
Santiago, Chile
USDA Zone
9b
In all fairness, the political terms "Left" and "Right" are not readily transferable between South America, Asia, Europe, and the USA, which makes it very confusing for people following U.S. politics from abroad.

For example, by most measures, the classic and (justifiably) most vilified "right-wing" political party in modern history is the Nazi Party of 20th Century Germany, which was fascist, exercised tight-fisted centralized government control, were socialists, and rejected individual rights in favor of the good of the whole (Motherland).

Yet, the most right-wing faction of American politics, today, are Libertarians, which are a faction of the Republican Party, and are the closest thing to Classic Thomas Jefferson-style/18th Century "Liberals". Libertarians generally want to trim Federal government control to the bone, return power to the States, champion individual rights (above the government), want to legalize/end restrictions on just about everything related to person freedom (drugs, marriage, guns, etc.), and support free-market principles with very little government interference. Hardly what folks in other parts of the world would call right-wing.
Yeah... left, right it will be hahhaha
 

Lazylightningny

Masterpiece
Messages
2,257
Reaction score
2,107
Location
Downstate New York, Zone 6b
USDA Zone
6b
Up until the Democrats unloaded their unsubstantiated, straight-face lies upon the man, he was among the top-five most respected Federal Appellate Court Judges in the land. Given that none of what is being propagated can be substantiated, nothing should have changed.

Here's a little humor piece a friend of mine (Chuck Porretto) wrote to characterize what has occurred. IMHO, it's just about this sleazy, too:

Dems..... Mr. Kavamaugh, When did you first become aware that someone accused you of being an accomplice of Ted Bundy when you were 8 years old?
Judge Kavanaugh.... Well, I'm, I was not an accomplice of Ted Bundy.
Dems...... Stop with the word games, and tell us when you first heard the accusation ...
Judge Kavanaugh.... Well I'm, I guess it was Tuesday.
Dems.... Ah hah. Well we know that It was not Tuesday. You heard about it on Monday. You are not fit to be on the Supreme Court, and your lies means that most likely you were in fact an accomplice of Ted Bundy.
Judge Kavanaugh.... No way. This is an outrage. I will fight to protect my good name...
Dems... Oh dear, your temperament is disgualifying.
Dems.... Did you throw ice in college?
Judge Kavanaugh... Well let me explain
Dems... Are you aware that ice is the cause of the Titanic sinking?
Judge Kavanaugh.... This is crazy...
Dems.... How dare you call me crazy... Do you call all women crazy?
NEWS UPDATE...... This is Rachel Madow..... Judge Kavanaugh calls all women Crazy.....
Dems..... Mr. Kavanaugh; Are you anti Science?
Judge Kavanaugh..... No, I beli....
Dems.... Stop taking so long to answer.... So are you aware of and recognize Einstien' s theory of relativity?
Judge Kavanaugh... Yes, I studied about....
Dems... That's quite enough..... So you do accept the fact that time travel is possible?
Judge Kavanaugh.... Well. I..... I...
Dems.... Are you aware that you have been accused of traveling back in time, and are in fact the architect of Hitler's Final Solution?
Judge Kavanaugh... That is preposterous....
Dems.... Why are you so belligerent. Your temperament is very disconcerting..... Now tell us.... Do you black out before or after you murder Train loads of Jews?
Judge Kavanaugh... I do not black out.
Dems... Stop lying, We have an anonymous tip from a young woman who was at Auschwitz that says other wise... Do you black out before or after your murderous sprees?
Judge Kavanaugh.... I do not ...
Dems.... OMG answer this... Did you sleep last night.
Judge Kavanaugh... Um yes..
Dems... And we're you unconscience when you are sleeping?
Judge Kavanaugh.... Um I guess so...
Dems... Now pay attention Jew Killer; When people black out, are they unconscience?
Judge Kavanaugh.... Well I guess yes....
Dems.... ah ha.... So you admit that people that black out are unconscience, and you also admit that you were unconscience just last night. I think the American people are smart enough to see through your lies and obfuscation.
Judge Kavanaugh.... This is preposterous....
Dems.... Stop with the anger Judge, It is very unbecoming. Now Tell us... Exactly how many dirty Jews did you murder?
Judge Kavanaugh.... ARRRRGHH. I did not murder any dirty Jews....
NEWS ALERT..... This is Anderson Cooper, Judge Kavanaugh just went on an anti Semetic tirade, and Called all Jewish Americans dirty Jews.
Obviously an exaggeration, but this is exactly what they are doing to this poor guy.
 

MHBonsai

Chumono
Messages
679
Reaction score
2,093
Location
Nashville, TN
USDA Zone
7a
My statement above is not based at all on what the Democrats have brought to the table. Like I said, I don't agree with how either party has handled this.

Temperament. Nonpartisan. Complete honesty, an an awareness of the nature of American people today. that's what I'll be looking for in a Supreme Court Justice.
 

Vance Wood

Lord Mugo
Messages
14,002
Reaction score
16,913
Location
Michigan
USDA Zone
5-6
I can't say I'm satisfied with the behavior of either party right now, regardless of political affiliation.

I keep asking myself...is Kavanaugh really the absolute best the USA has to offer?

I mean I feel for the guy, his life is totally flipped upside down here. I won't pretend to judge of if it is deserved or not. But how is the USA unable to find an upstanding citizen that both parties can agree is worthy of sitting in the chair for a lifetime. Kavanaugh ain't it.
That question is irrelevant at this point. If there is a better person than Kavanaugh, which is debateable, do you think this person would want to put them self and family through what this nominee is going through? This is the real threat we are facing at this moment.
 

MHBonsai

Chumono
Messages
679
Reaction score
2,093
Location
Nashville, TN
USDA Zone
7a
That question is irrelevant at this point. If there is a better person than Kavanaugh, which is debateable, do you think this person would want to put them self and family through what this nominee is going through? This is the real threat we are facing at this moment.

Completely agree.
 

barrosinc

Masterpiece
Messages
4,127
Reaction score
4,691
Location
Santiago, Chile
USDA Zone
9b
Can someone make a for dummies summary of what this is about?

I read that this dude is going for an important position of the supreme court but has a new allegation for something 30 years ago that nobody remembers and trump had the fbi investigating and people claim it has political agenda behind the allegations?? Is that close?
 

AlainK

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
5,394
Reaction score
9,489
Location
Orléans, France, Europe
USDA Zone
9A
In all fairness, the political terms "Left" and "Right" are not readily transferable between South America, Asia, Europe, and the USA, which makes it very confusing for people following U.S. politics from abroad.

For example, by most measures, the classic and (justifiably) most vilified "right-wing" political party in modern history is the Nazi Party of 20th Century Germany, which was fascist, exercised tight-fisted centralized government control, were socialists, and rejected individual rights in favor of the good of the whole (Motherland).

Yet, the most right-wing faction of American politics, today, are Libertarians, which are a faction of the Republican Party, and are the closest thing to Classic Thomas Jefferson-style/18th Century "Liberals". Libertarians generally want to trim Federal government control to the bone, return power to the States, champion individual rights (above the government), want to legalize/end restrictions on just about everything related to person freedom (drugs, marriage, guns, etc.), and support free-market principles with very little government interference. Hardly what folks in other parts of the world would call right-wing.

This is post I like : it's well-argumented, based on sound references and thus worth considering, or debating.

One can disagree with the interpretation of what is excellent reference, but it's well above the initial posting. Thanks for taking the debate a step higher.
 

AlainK

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
5,394
Reaction score
9,489
Location
Orléans, France, Europe
USDA Zone
9A
a new allegation for something 30 years ago that nobody remembers

Well if one can't even remember and assume how drunk they used to get they were in their 20s, they oughtn't sit in the Supreme Court for the rest of their life.

What was Alzheiler's first name?

...

...

...

See, it begins like that.
 

Lazylightningny

Masterpiece
Messages
2,257
Reaction score
2,107
Location
Downstate New York, Zone 6b
USDA Zone
6b
Can someone make a for dummies summary of what this is about?

I read that this dude is going for an important position of the supreme court but has a new allegation for something 30 years ago that nobody remembers and trump had the fbi investigating and people claim it has political agenda behind the allegations?? Is that close?
Pretty much, in a nutshell.
 

BuckeyeBonsai

Seedling
Messages
15
Reaction score
15
Location
Ohio
there is a better person than Kavanaugh.
Yes, there probably is a better person somewhere. That being said, I've yet to see corroborated evidence that Kavanaugh is actually a bad guy, so there is really no justification so much of what has been said about the man so far. Did he get really drunk on occasion? I'm sure he probably did. Do I think that that has any bearing whatsoever on his character now? Given the fact that he has passed six FBI background checks (here comes #7), i'd say not. This isn't about women being able to fight back against sexual abuse (they, and anyone else, should be allowed and encouraged to do so), this is about people demanding that due process be thrown out the window to punish a man for unsubstantiated claims.

Kind Regards
 

just.wing.it

Deadwood Head
Messages
12,141
Reaction score
17,549
Location
Just South of the Mason Dixon
USDA Zone
6B
Yes, there probably is a better person somewhere. That being said, I've yet to see corroborated evidence that Kavanaugh is actually a bad guy, so there is really no justification so much of what has been said about the man so far. Did he get really drunk on occasion? I'm sure he probably did. Do I think that that has any bearing whatsoever on his character now? Given the fact that he has passed six FBI background checks (here comes #7), i'd say not. This isn't about women being able to fight back against sexual abuse (they, and anyone else, should be allowed and encouraged to do so), this is about people demanding that due process be thrown out the window to punish a man for unsubstantiated claims.

Kind Regards
Its a witch hunt.
Same playbook they try on anyone they think may be a threat to their billion dollar abortion clinics....lets just be honest...Clarence Thomas....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom