LG Rock Elm

Lars Grimm

Chumono
Messages
837
Reaction score
1,606
Location
Durham, North Carolina
USDA Zone
7
Hi All,

Here is a progression thread for a rock elm in my collection. This was the first big tree I purchased back in December 2016 at the Winter Silhouette show. It had been collected a few years prior by a senior club member. Here it is as purchased. To my eye at the time, I felt there were a few problems with the tree. First, the lower primary branches were too thin. Second, the apex after the trunk chop was too tall. Third, I wanted to expand the width of the lower branches. Many of the branches felt very flat to me . Finally, there was a big gap between the lowest right branch and the one above, but there was a branch going straight back.

IMG_2024.JPG

Here was my photoshop working plan.

Plan.jpg

Fast forward two years to 2018. I completed an apical chop and regrew a leader. The lower branches are a little thicker (not much), but I got a lot more vertical movement in the branches. There is also a slight rotation after a repot.


IMG_3636.JPG

Fast forward to 2020 after a fall pruning. The lower branches continue to thicken, but slowly. I left the lower two branches to grow one foot beyond the silhouette this year and will continue to do so to encourage thickening. There are some other smaller interior branches that I am trying to build up to improve some areas. The ramification in many areas has clearly improved. I think the silhouette is looking much better. I probably want to extend the mid/upper left a bit more. The trunk chop continues to be problematic even though you can't see it from the front. I find this species very slow to callus. I am going to start using the cut paste with hormone. I also discovered some soft pulpy wood at the chop site. I dug it out and treated with wood hardener. I plan to fill with a cement before covering with cut paste.

IMG_5722.jpg

Comments, suggestions, and feedback are always appreciated.

Lars
 

BrianBay9

Masterpiece
Messages
2,781
Reaction score
5,551
Location
Fresno, CA
USDA Zone
9
Hi All,

Here is a progression thread for a rock elm in my collection. This was the first big tree I purchased back in December 2016 at the Winter Silhouette show. It had been collected a few years prior by a senior club member. Here it is as purchased. To my eye at the time, I felt there were a few problems with the tree. First, the lower primary branches were too thin. Second, the apex after the trunk chop was too tall. Third, I wanted to expand the width of the lower branches. Many of the branches felt very flat to me . Finally, there was a big gap between the lowest right branch and the one above, but there was a branch going straight back.

View attachment 339914

Here was my photoshop working plan.

View attachment 339917

Fast forward two years to 2018. I completed an apical chop and regrew a leader. The lower branches are a little thicker (not much), but I got a lot more vertical movement in the branches. There is also a slight rotation after a repot.


View attachment 339916

Fast forward to 2020 after a fall pruning. The lower branches continue to thicken, but slowly. I left the lower two branches to grow one foot beyond the silhouette this year and will continue to do so to encourage thickening. There are some other smaller interior branches that I am trying to build up to improve some areas. The ramification in many areas has clearly improved. I think the silhouette is looking much better. I probably want to extend the mid/upper left a bit more. The trunk chop continues to be problematic even though you can't see it from the front. I find this species very slow to callus. I am going to start using the cut paste with hormone. I also discovered some soft pulpy wood at the chop site. I dug it out and treated with wood hardener. I plan to fill with a cement before covering with cut paste.

View attachment 339918

Comments, suggestions, and feedback are always appreciated.

Lars

Small suggestion, and maybe not that important. Personally I like to see the apex over the base of the tree and I thought that was where you were going. In your last pic it looks like you're taking the apex back to the left. I would suggest moving it to the right to keep it over the tree's base, rather than over the vertical part of the trunk, if that makes sense.
 

Lars Grimm

Chumono
Messages
837
Reaction score
1,606
Location
Durham, North Carolina
USDA Zone
7
Small suggestion, and maybe not that important. Personally I like to see the apex over the base of the tree and I thought that was where you were going. In your last pic it looks like you're taking the apex back to the left. I would suggest moving it to the right to keep it over the tree's base, rather than over the vertical part of the trunk, if that makes sense.
Interesting observation that I hadn't considered. There is certainly a lot that I can do with the apex. Additionally, I can slightly change the repotting angle as well. Thanks for the suggestion!
 

Tieball

Masterpiece
Messages
3,137
Reaction score
3,213
Location
Michigan. 6a
USDA Zone
6a
Really nice work on the tree. The apex chop was a good decision. The tree looks much better now. To me....the apex movement to the left looks natural. There’s more weight on the left as if the tree was near the edge of a forest and grew stronger in that direction. I like the not-perfectly-balanced image you have. The tree is different than every other formula tree.
 
Top Bottom