Many many pots for sale on my Etsy store

M. Frary

Bonsai Godzilla
Messages
14,307
Reaction score
22,116
Location
Mio Michigan
USDA Zone
4
They look like ceramics.
They don't tend to last where I live.
 

M. Frary

Bonsai Godzilla
Messages
14,307
Reaction score
22,116
Location
Mio Michigan
USDA Zone
4
Northern Michigan.
I've tried some ceramics but they tend to crack during winter if they have trees in them.
Maybe they absorb water from the drain holes into the ceramic and it freezes and breaks them.
Good looking pots though.
 

StoneCloud

Omono
Messages
1,314
Reaction score
1,917
Location
North Carolina
USDA Zone
7b
Most of the US experiences winter and the freeze thaw cycle is something we all know too well.

Have you tested any of your pots with trees in them over a few seasons ?
 
Messages
24
Reaction score
21
I have.. none have broken yet.

I live in Annapolis MD. The winters here are not terrible. They have been covered in snow and ice. But not and sub-zero

-Anthony
 

atlarsenal

Omono
Messages
1,294
Reaction score
4,812
Location
Kennesaw, GA
USDA Zone
7b
I have bought one of your pots on EBay before. How do I search for your stuff on Etsy?
 

Bonsai Nut

Nuttier than your average Nut
Messages
12,420
Reaction score
27,860
Location
Charlotte area, North Carolina
USDA Zone
8a
I would give your pots an "A" for looks, but I would be worried about how they would hold up to the rigors of being used as an actual bonsai pot.

What you should do is go hang out at someone's house when they are repotting some of their trees after they have become root-bound. Pots need to be sturdy enough to put up with a fair amount of abuse. Not just freeze/thaw, but they have to be able to have anchor wires placed through the drain holes that are secured to the tree's rootball, and they will be constantly handled, and have tools poking and prodding them.

With old bonsai pots, often the "patina" that builds up on old a pot from years of constant use is highly valued. Chips not so much :) So you have to think about building a pot that will put up with that abuse for decades without chipping or cracking. Just as an example, here is an unglazed stoneware pot from an artist I really like. See how sturdy it looks?

I'm not trying to get you to change your aesthetic or design - just your sturdiness :)

510.jpg
 

Giga

Masterpiece
Messages
3,813
Reaction score
4,722
Location
Virginia beach, VA
USDA Zone
7-8
I would give your pots an "A" for looks, but I would be worried about how they would hold up to the rigors of being used as an actual bonsai pot.

What you should do is go hang out at someone's house when they are repotting some of their trees after they have become root-bound. Pots need to be sturdy enough to put up with a fair amount of abuse. Not just freeze/thaw, but they have to be able to have anchor wires placed through the drain holes that are secured to the tree's rootball, and they will be constantly handled, and have tools poking and prodding them.

With old bonsai pots, often the "patina" that builds up on old a pot from years of constant use is highly valued. Chips not so much :) So you have to think about building a pot that will put up with that abuse for decades without chipping or cracking. Just as an example, here is an unglazed stoneware pot from an artist I really like. See how sturdy it looks?

I'm not trying to get you to change your aesthetic or design - just your sturdiness :)

View attachment 178055

I have to agree
 
Messages
24
Reaction score
21
I would give your pots an "A" for looks, but I would be worried about how they would hold up to the rigors of being used as an actual bonsai pot.

What you should do is go hang out at someone's house when they are repotting some of their trees after they have become root-bound. Pots need to be sturdy enough to put up with a fair amount of abuse. Not just freeze/thaw, but they have to be able to have anchor wires placed through the drain holes that are secured to the tree's rootball, and they will be constantly handled, and have tools poking and prodding them.

With old bonsai pots, often the "patina" that builds up on old a pot from years of constant use is highly valued. Chips not so much :) So you have to think about building a pot that will put up with that abuse for decades without chipping or cracking. Just as an example, here is an unglazed stoneware pot from an artist I really like. See how sturdy it looks?

I'm not trying to get you to change your aesthetic or design - just your sturdiness :)

View attachment 178055
Only my 5 1/2” pots are thin... I do price them accordingly. At $19.95 with shipping included... it’s not a bad deal. My larger pots are thicker.

I will indeed heed your wisdom. All my future small pots I’ll add some thickness.

Thank you for the advice

-Anthony
 

rockm

Spuds Moyogi
Messages
14,182
Reaction score
22,181
Location
Fairfax Va.
USDA Zone
7
I would give your pots an "A" for looks, but I would be worried about how they would hold up to the rigors of being used as an actual bonsai pot.

What you should do is go hang out at someone's house when they are repotting some of their trees after they have become root-bound. Pots need to be sturdy enough to put up with a fair amount of abuse. Not just freeze/thaw, but they have to be able to have anchor wires placed through the drain holes that are secured to the tree's rootball, and they will be constantly handled, and have tools poking and prodding them.

With old bonsai pots, often the "patina" that builds up on old a pot from years of constant use is highly valued. Chips not so much :) So you have to think about building a pot that will put up with that abuse for decades without chipping or cracking. Just as an example, here is an unglazed stoneware pot from an artist I really like. See how sturdy it looks?

I'm not trying to get you to change your aesthetic or design - just your sturdiness :)

View attachment 178055
I would tend to agree. Your pots look pretty flimsy for use even in this area. Bonsai are first and foremost functional pottery (preferably stoneware) build to withstand long-term (like decades or even centuries) use and abuse. While pretty glazes and painting is nice, I'm looking for pots that can actually be used.

Would be useful to know if you do bonsai and how long you've been doing it.

While $20 for a pot is dirt cheap, buying three of them because they all break isn't...
 
Messages
24
Reaction score
21
I do Bonsai, been doing it for about 10 years. I have been using my own pots for almost 5. I haven’t broken any yet, other the dropping one on occasion.

None of my pots are “painted” all glaze or colored slip.

I will heed advice and I’ll make a few batches of stoneware.

I haven’t let any get rootbound... perhaps I will. I would like to do more stress on them. And like I have said... the only thin pots I do are the small ones. All my larger sizes are made more the 1/4” and very sturdy.

-Anthony
 

rockm

Spuds Moyogi
Messages
14,182
Reaction score
22,181
Location
Fairfax Va.
USDA Zone
7
I do Bonsai, been doing it for about 10 years. I have been using my own pots for almost 5. I haven’t broken any yet, other the dropping one on occasion.

None of my pots are “painted” all glaze or colored slip.

I will heed advice and I’ll make a few batches of stoneware.

I haven’t let any get rootbound... perhaps I will. I would like to do more stress on them. And like I have said... the only thin pots I do are the small ones. All my larger sizes are made more the 1/4” and very sturdy.

-Anthony
I guess there's bonsai and BONSAI. Stress on bonsai pots doesn't come from roots. It comes from weight of soil and trees, and weather. Freezing soil in pots left outside will crack thin walled pots pretty easily, especially if the pot has a design with an incurved rim. To get a real-world stress test, fill the pot up with a tree and soil. Water it well, bury it in mulch in November in the backyard and overwinter it there until March. That treatment will probably show you some weaknesses.

BTW, Do you have larger trees--like over three inches in diameter that require a gallon or two of bonsai soil in their pots? or are you more experienced with shohin and mame trees? Makes a big difference.

To get a feel for what makes a good bonsai pot, you have to handle good bonsai pots. Don't know if you have done this, but owning, using and handling Japanese tokoname made pots, or some of the more well known American and western bonsai potters' stuff can greatly inform how you make your own.
 
Top Bottom