BonsaiSniper
Mame
I personally like it, it does degrade after a while though...
If you could find a size bigger than their MVP and where more than half a bag isn't wasted, it could be really good.
Has it really broken down or are you seeing the fines accumulate? The stuff I have is pretty high fired, but I don't really have a hard freeze-thaw compared to you probably.
I still use some in my growing out stuff, I've mostly switched to 50/50 perlite and potting soil. I don't have turface as a main component in anything though.
thats a great website to to buy kelp extract.The article in this url below explains a lot about the physical properties of commonly used inorganic components. Even though it is from a website pertaining to orchids I found it to be very informative on the micro structure and internal porosity of turface (lightweight expanded clay aggregate), diatomaceous earth, pumice, and scoria.
Mineral Buildup in Inorganic Media › First Rays LLC
Mineral buildup in inorganic media can be reduced by following a few recommended cultural techniquesfirstrays.com
I have been using Mule Mix for a number of years now (I have a local source here in Western Kentucky.) I can't compare its properties, particle size, etc. to Turface, since I have not used the latter, but if Turface particles are flat, I can say that is not the case with Mule Mix. I do sieve and wash it to remove dust-like and other finer particles, but otherwise use it as is. As others have said for Turface, I also thoroughly wash used Mule Mix and reuse it with no ill effects. There is little break-down, and it does not need any sieving, only good clean-up the second time around.There is a calcined clay product similar to turface but larger particles called Mule Mix, https://www.domyown.com/southern-athletic-field-mule-mix-816-conditioner-p-9628.html
I've found it difficult to source but would bet it would be a better size for soil mixes as compared to turface.
3 years ago I switched from my turface/pine bark/granite mix to a napa8822/pumice/lava rock mix.
!SI used turface MVP for years, sifting and throwing away anything smaller than 3mm. I would throw away half of each bag. Not very cost effective. If I tried sifting 2mm and larger, I would get bubbles coming to the surface every time I watered, leading me to believe there were dry pockets in the soil, not a good thing.
3 years ago I switched from my turface/pine bark/granite mix to a napa8822/pumice/lava rock mix. I notice my trees require less frequent watering. They are much less likely to have wilting leaves in the summer.
Then this year I got some akadama and I'm trying the classic APL mix, we'll see if I prefer it to the napa mix at the end of this year.
Yup 1/4" "Turface" that's what I use in place of akadama in my mix.Bonsai Jack Monto Clay solves this problem. It’s from the same source as turface, different shape, larger size, more expensive.
3 years ago I switched from my turface/pine bark/granite mix to a napa8822/pumice/lava rock mix.