Shibui
Imperial Masterpiece
I also regularly bare root pines - JBP and JRP. Neither seem to be too worried about it so far so I hope they don't hear about it being fatal. Defining 'Bare root': All soil shaken off or scraped out with chopstick reasonably easily. Not washed off clean.
We also have a growing cohort of experienced bonsai growers over here repotting conifers from late summer through to mid autumn. Some also repotting deciduous at that time too, usually less aggressive than in spring root pruning.
Again, very different climate in my little corner but it seems to work.
I have found I can do quite a number of things the experts told us were impossible.
No-one is forcing you to bare root pines or repot other than spring. If you want to keep a closed mind by all means go right ahead.
We also have a growing cohort of experienced bonsai growers over here repotting conifers from late summer through to mid autumn. Some also repotting deciduous at that time too, usually less aggressive than in spring root pruning.
Again, very different climate in my little corner but it seems to work.
I have found I can do quite a number of things the experts told us were impossible.
No-one is forcing you to bare root pines or repot other than spring. If you want to keep a closed mind by all means go right ahead.