Sandcounty
Seedling
What size screen should be used to prepare soil for shohin sized trees? The 1/4" size at Fleet Farm is labeled as 5,6mm, is this too large? I'm sifting chicken grit, lava rock, and bark. Sand
Soil Sifters
- Thread starter Sandcounty
- Start date
Brent
Mame
Sandcounty
1/8 inch hardware cloth is perfect. See if you can find this at a hardware store. It used to be pretty common, but it is getting harder to find in this smaller size. Just nail or staple it to a simple wooden frame and you have a great and inexpensive sifter.
Brent
EvergreenGardenworks.com
see our blog at http://BonsaiNurseryman.typepad.com
1/8 inch hardware cloth is perfect. See if you can find this at a hardware store. It used to be pretty common, but it is getting harder to find in this smaller size. Just nail or staple it to a simple wooden frame and you have a great and inexpensive sifter.
Brent
EvergreenGardenworks.com
see our blog at http://BonsaiNurseryman.typepad.com
Anonymous User
Banned
Make three frames and use different sized screens, then stack them, the larger sized screen on top and the smallest on the bottom. In this way you do it all at once, and if you catch the fines on the bottom, save them for mame, moss, and muck.
Will
Will
Sandcounty
Seedling
Brent,
I went to several hardware stores, a different Fleet Farm, and a Wild Birds store looking for the 1/8" size hardware cloth. I must've talked to twelve individuals who looked like they would know about such things. Not one had ever seen that size. Must be a midwest thing. I'll keep looking though, I'm sure I'll come across it eventually.
Will,
That's a great idea, just as soon as I find the right screen.
Sand
I went to several hardware stores, a different Fleet Farm, and a Wild Birds store looking for the 1/8" size hardware cloth. I must've talked to twelve individuals who looked like they would know about such things. Not one had ever seen that size. Must be a midwest thing. I'll keep looking though, I'm sure I'll come across it eventually.
Will,
That's a great idea, just as soon as I find the right screen.
Sand
Screens for sifting
I found 1/4 inch and 1/8 inch hardware cloth at both Lowe's and Home Depot here in NC. I've found the cloth in two different places. Sometimes it's outside in the Garden center with the dog kennel and fencing and I've also found it inside in the lumber section and the hardware section.
I built two wood frames as Brent suggested. I also stack them as Will mentioned. Instead of three different size screens I'm only using two. To screen the fines I actually use the screen cloth used for screened doors or screened porches. I believe this is about 1/16 inch probably. So, for instance, when I screen pine bark soil conditioner I stack the 1/4 inch screen on top of the 1/16 inch screen and sift. Lift out the big stuff with the 1/4 screen and let the fines fall through the 1/16. Seems to work fairly well.
I found 1/4 inch and 1/8 inch hardware cloth at both Lowe's and Home Depot here in NC. I've found the cloth in two different places. Sometimes it's outside in the Garden center with the dog kennel and fencing and I've also found it inside in the lumber section and the hardware section.
I built two wood frames as Brent suggested. I also stack them as Will mentioned. Instead of three different size screens I'm only using two. To screen the fines I actually use the screen cloth used for screened doors or screened porches. I believe this is about 1/16 inch probably. So, for instance, when I screen pine bark soil conditioner I stack the 1/4 inch screen on top of the 1/16 inch screen and sift. Lift out the big stuff with the 1/4 screen and let the fines fall through the 1/16. Seems to work fairly well.
Attachments
Pioneersnt
Seedling
- Messages
- 7
- Reaction score
- 0
This is a set of sifters and rocker base that I built a while ago. I used 1/2, 1/4, and 1/8 inch screen. I found all the hardware cloth at True Value Hardware. I thought about making a fourth using 1/16 screen but thought material this small would be too fine.
Should I rethink this? Is material 1/16>1/8 usable?
Should I rethink this? Is material 1/16>1/8 usable?
Attachments
bonsaibaka
Sapling
I've found it here in Austin, TX at Home Depot and Lowe's. Keep looking, you'll find it.
I screwed fence pickets (after sawing off the pointed tip) into a frame shape and stapled the screen on with a staple gun. I made 4 different sized frames so they would nest and I could store them easily. Screen sizes are: 1/2", 1/4", 1/8" and window screen. The window screen is on the largest frame so I can set the larger screen size on top (catty-corner) and catch the "good stuff" in between, just like Will suggests.
Cheers,
Mike
I screwed fence pickets (after sawing off the pointed tip) into a frame shape and stapled the screen on with a staple gun. I made 4 different sized frames so they would nest and I could store them easily. Screen sizes are: 1/2", 1/4", 1/8" and window screen. The window screen is on the largest frame so I can set the larger screen size on top (catty-corner) and catch the "good stuff" in between, just like Will suggests.
Cheers,
Mike
Last edited:
bonsaibaka
Sapling
Thanks Irene. The nesting was a matter of necessity in the tiny duplex I used to live in.
The smallest frame is about 1 foot square. I built that one first and then built the bigger ones around it leaving about an 1/8th to a quarter inch clearance all around. The garden pickets are about 1 1/2" x 3/4" in width and thickness. These are light weight and I can process an amazing amount of material quickly. My arms and back suffer though
. I really like the rocker frame that Pioneersnt built! My wife saw me looking at the picture and said "Uh oh, guess we're going to Home Depot".
Mike
The smallest frame is about 1 foot square. I built that one first and then built the bigger ones around it leaving about an 1/8th to a quarter inch clearance all around. The garden pickets are about 1 1/2" x 3/4" in width and thickness. These are light weight and I can process an amazing amount of material quickly. My arms and back suffer though
. I really like the rocker frame that Pioneersnt built! My wife saw me looking at the picture and said "Uh oh, guess we're going to Home Depot". Mike
Pioneersnt
Seedling
- Messages
- 7
- Reaction score
- 0
Dang, you guys are full of great ideas!
Ed how about the plans for the rocker base?
Irene
Didn't have plans, just kinda put it together. I could draw some up if ya want.
Pioneersnt
Seedling
- Messages
- 7
- Reaction score
- 0
Yes Please!
Irene
OK, I'll take some measurements and put it together for ya sometime this week.
cambi
Seedling
I had a plan for a sifter, but the cost of hardware cloth or screen was high and it would be cheaper to buy a bonsai sifter, online.
Ken Duncan
Yamadori
The soil sifters that I have seen that are sold from Japan you can only use one screen at a time, by making your own you can use 3 or more screen at one time.
I made frames with 1/4", 1/8", and screen wire (1/16"), 12" square and 2" deep, to sift soil many years ago and they are still being used today. I stack them up 1/16" on the bottom, 1/8" in the middle and the 1/4" on top, put the dry, must be very dry, soil component in the 1/4" shake well, get rid of what remains on the 1/4" hardware cloth and what goes through the screen wire (1/16").You will end up with 1/4" soil components and 1/8" soil components, you can mix them together for main soil or use the 1/8" for small trees.
Each soil component is done separate and mixed as needed ( 1/3 turface, 1/3 composted pine bark, 1/3 river sand ETC.).
Window screen and 1/4" hardware cloth are easy to find at you hardware store, Lowe's and Home Depot, here is a link for 1/8" hardware cloth that is used for Bee hives, it is much harder to find and you do not need a whole roll of it.
http://www.honeyrunapiaries.com/sto....html?osCsid=3d2a968ef94b892ef5ba525d77312c65
Ken
I made frames with 1/4", 1/8", and screen wire (1/16"), 12" square and 2" deep, to sift soil many years ago and they are still being used today. I stack them up 1/16" on the bottom, 1/8" in the middle and the 1/4" on top, put the dry, must be very dry, soil component in the 1/4" shake well, get rid of what remains on the 1/4" hardware cloth and what goes through the screen wire (1/16").You will end up with 1/4" soil components and 1/8" soil components, you can mix them together for main soil or use the 1/8" for small trees.
Each soil component is done separate and mixed as needed ( 1/3 turface, 1/3 composted pine bark, 1/3 river sand ETC.).
Window screen and 1/4" hardware cloth are easy to find at you hardware store, Lowe's and Home Depot, here is a link for 1/8" hardware cloth that is used for Bee hives, it is much harder to find and you do not need a whole roll of it.
http://www.honeyrunapiaries.com/sto....html?osCsid=3d2a968ef94b892ef5ba525d77312c65
Ken
Last edited:
rockm
Spuds Moyogi
Screening chicken grit is mostly unnecessary, if you're using crushed granite (Granni Grit) as all grades are screened at the quarry...
Rick Moquin
Omono
Not where I come from. Although close they still require screening.
FrankP999
Shohin
Be sure to avoid breathing the dust especially granite dust. Nasty stuff to inhale
Frank
Frank
Bonsai Nut
Nuttier than your average Nut
Hey Pioneer - you ever pan for gold? I'm actually not kidding - that setup reminds me of a dry panning setup people use out West for placer gold.
treebeard55
Chumono
Do you have Ace Hardware in your area? That's where I get my 1/8" hardware cloth.
