Mikecheck123
Omono
Yes, you were offensive. We were having a perfectly enjoyable conversation about Peter meeting the queen when you slid in and started sniping.
Thoughts on Peter Chan? (Herons Bonsai)
- Thread starter Blimpsandmtn
- Start date
Chopsie
Shohin
It’s not a closed conversation is it, I’ve not rudely interrupted anything this is a open board , the threads titled thoughts on Peter Chan.
I have simply posted my thoughts, sorry that you don’t like them lol
I’m not sniping my friend it’s called having a different opinion .
And no I wasn’t offensive about anybody, that’s not why I’m here!
Dzhokar
Mame
These days people get their panties all wadded if you tell them the sky is blue.
rockm
Spuds Moyogi
The photos of Chan and the queen are kind of relevant to his abilities and notoriety. Yes, his trees can be a bit less than the professional standard these days, but the yardstick for measuring them and Chan have changed dramatically.
When those photos were taken in the 80's or early 90's bonsai was in its infancy in the West. There was no Internet. Most Western Japanese-trained professionals were still in diapers, or weren't even born yet.
Chan brought attention and a level of skill that was pretty rare back then. He made a big contribution to the art that isn't easily matched.
When those photos were taken in the 80's or early 90's bonsai was in its infancy in the West. There was no Internet. Most Western Japanese-trained professionals were still in diapers, or weren't even born yet.
Chan brought attention and a level of skill that was pretty rare back then. He made a big contribution to the art that isn't easily matched.
Thatguy85
Sapling
Peter was the reason I got into bonsai, just 3 years ago. His way of bringing the art of bonsai to the public, and to me, is very soothing and catching. Since the beginning of my journey I got acquainted with Bjorn's videos and started visiting this board (and Mirai, Bonsai Empire). I think it's most fascinating that his approach works, especially since it -often- seems to be so different that what I read here (for example his very organically rich soil mixes, even on Junipers and his use of sphagnum moss). And while I can see that he works very differently than, for example, Bjorn (in his videos at least, not sure how he works on refined material), it's super interesting to see that what he does, works. Again, it's fascinating and keeps me thinking. So to me he played a very important role -he got me into bonsai after all. Just my two eurocents.
Oh and I love that robin in his video's.
Oh and I love that robin in his video's.
bonsaiboy60077
Mame
I have been watching his videos, and have to say he is getting me out of my comfort zone and more willing to try things on my own.
Mikecheck123
Omono
His video on sowing Japanese maple seeds is a must watch for anyone who's messed around with a refrigerator and/or had to explain to their spouse why there's moldy seeds in the fruit drawer.
You'll never do that again! He makes it easy.
You'll never do that again! He makes it easy.
leatherback
The Treedeemer
Rightfully so. Have you seen the sky here right now
HorseloverFat
Squarepants with Conkers
Artists don't waste time tearing down other people's art/methods. They realize that "good" is mostly subjective, and don't aim for relative goals... why insult the way someone "get's down" with art... when you can focus on your OWN expression.
Conversely..
People who just make art (as apposed to artists) need a style, direction, "hero".. (or multiple heroes) to CLING to.. They normally have difficulties expressing themselves NON-contrived. These people often feel jealousy at others who CAN "create".. and spend their days criticizing SOME artists.. while doing their best to emulate OTHER artists.
Not sure if this is relevant HERE...
But this statement is relative MANY places.
Conversely..
People who just make art (as apposed to artists) need a style, direction, "hero".. (or multiple heroes) to CLING to.. They normally have difficulties expressing themselves NON-contrived. These people often feel jealousy at others who CAN "create".. and spend their days criticizing SOME artists.. while doing their best to emulate OTHER artists.
Not sure if this is relevant HERE...
But this statement is relative MANY places.
greenguy
Seedling
I love the guy. He reminds me of Bob Ross. I've binged a ton of his videos and loved every minute of it 
I really enjoyed this one although I didn’t hear the rain until he mentioned it and then couldn’t not hear it. Also the after slide says “before” ooops.
Peter and a Deshojo
Peter and a Deshojo
Adamski77
Shohin
Without Peter would be no counter to what everybody else is doing… without counter there is no progress…
If you don’t like him don’t watch but having contradicting opinions just fuel the growth… doesn’t have to fuel the hatred…
If you don’t like him don’t watch but having contradicting opinions just fuel the growth… doesn’t have to fuel the hatred…
bonsaiboy60077
Mame
I happen to like his videos a lot, and has gotten me interested in trees I normally would never have thought about getting, namely pines. I am planning a trip to the UK hopefully late fall or early spring and hoping to get to see his place and maybe purchase a tree from him.
Zerobear
Yamadori
Because of USDA regulations on plant importing into the USA, buying a tree in England and bringing it to the US is (sadly) very difficult and usually expensive. They must be fumigated and then quarantined by an authorized importer. I undesrtand why the requirements are strict, but believe you will find the process of meeting USDA regulations burdensome.
Last edited:
rockm
Spuds Moyogi
I wouldn't plan on bringing a tree back. It will be confiscated and destroyed at the port of entry in the U.S.
The importation process is rigorous and takes time--two years in an approved quarantine facility (here or in the U.K). including a bare root sterilization process-which can kill your tree.
This article touches on the process:
USDA APHIS | Bringing Bonsai to Washington, DC
www.aphis.usda.gov
Gr8tfuldad
Chumono
Yet I can fly back with a case ofI wouldn't plan on bringing a tree back. It will be confiscated and destroyed at the port of entry in the U.S.
The importation process is rigorous and takes time--two years in an approved quarantine facility (here or in the U.K). including a bare root sterilization process-which can kill your tree.
This article touches on the process:
USDA APHIS | Bringing Bonsai to Washington, DC
and no one says a word…
We're all Mad Here...🎩
Shohin
I think he's a great inspiration and his "don't overthink things approach" helps people like me who think too goddam much without doing...aside from this...............
We're all Mad Here...🎩
Shohin
Seems like Peter Chan is a bit like Dave Mustaine. Both loved and hated, yet an undeniable master of his craft.
Zerobear
Yamadori
Before I attempted to bring anything back, or even g over to look at a purchase, I would contact Brussel's Bonsai in Horn Lake, MS. They are licensed to do all of the USDA requirements and have the facilities to do them. They can help you decide if the hassle is worth it.I wouldn't plan on bringing a tree back. It will be confiscated and destroyed at the port of entry in the U.S.
The importation process is rigorous and takes time--two years in an approved quarantine facility (here or in the U.K). including a bare root sterilization process-which can kill your tree.
This article touches on the process:
USDA APHIS | Bringing Bonsai to Washington, DC
MacSpook
Yamadori
Yet I can fly back with a case of
Haven't you heard of the tazer shorts?
The robin, like Peter, is a superstar.
Similar threads
