to chop or not to chop
- Thread starter chappy56
- Start date
Chris Johnston
Omono
Everything depends on variety, zone, health of the tree, stage of development, weather this month, etc. etc. Pat answers are worth what one pays for them.
Chappy, more specific questions about specific trees you have might be more easily answered! Check out my site, www.bonsaikc.com, and my blog, Sashi-no-eda Bonsai Blog, for some good information on a variety of subjects.
Anonymous User
Banned
Brent Walston, who is quite knowledgeable on developing stock for bonsai, wrote a bit about trunk chopping and growing large trunks here. Some discussion on trunk chopping can be found here. Personally, I have trunk chopped in the early spring with good results. This has given time for buds and then new shoots to develop and harden before the onslaught of Michigan winters.
Will
Will
BONSAI_OUTLAW
Banned
It seems to me like most trees do well when chopped in the late winter/early spring with the exception of maples which do best if chopped in mid summer. (I don't really work with tropicals so I don't know about them)
Chris Johnston
Omono
I have to reiterate, the varieties of experience with trunk chopping or any technique vary tremendously. You will find my experience with trunk chopping my large trident maple here.
Alas, this tree has assumed permanent dormancy due to no fault of the trunk chop, it was the other end that got it
.
Alas, this tree has assumed permanent dormancy due to no fault of the trunk chop, it was the other end that got it
.
BONSAI_OUTLAW
Banned
What an outstanding article and piece of material Chris. It seems like the last pictures were taken back in 2005 however. Can you please post some new pics of this tree or send them to me via email? I as you know adore Tridents and I would love to follow the progress of this tree.
Chris Johnston
Omono
If you notice, I mentioned that the tree is no longer among the living. Ambitious root work combined with traveling full time and a lawn guy who moved the sprinkler conspired to deprive me of a tree that was coming along very nicely. Mostly I blame my mother.
BONSAI_OUTLAW
Banned
......omg......
Chris Johnston
Omono
I know, don't you just blame my mother too?
| Thread starter | Similar threads | Forum | Replies | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | When to Trunk Chop? | New to Bonsai | 4 | |
| R | Collected Juniper Branch Chop? | Junipers | 5 | |
|
Nursery deciduous- air layer or trunk chop? | New to Bonsai | 9 | |
| K | Burr Oak Trunk Chop | New to Bonsai | 9 | |
| M | Black hills spruce trunk chop | General Discussion | 3 |