There are a few Pinus bungeana out there as bonsai. I have a few in the works; also just bought 2 pounds of seed. If anyone has one or has worked with them, please PM me as I'm researching techniques to train them. My best one was in a grow bed for a few years and a deer ate all the needles off. Now it has twice as many branches
. The seeds are to start some controlled experiments.
The key for bark exfoliation seems to be exposure to sunlight. I've owned 5 of the cultivars, but the graft unions have always been rough. 'Silver Ghost' seems the most appealing of cultivars, with 'Rowe Arboretum' being the least.
I have a few seedling Pinus bungeana finishing their 3rd summer. Big green needles, in bundles of 2 & or 3, pretty thick. So far seedlings in Anderson flats (15 x 15 x 4 inches) on the ground are winter hardy in zone 5b far north 'burbs of Chicago. First summer was juvenile foliage, looked like a seedling spruce, but bright green. In same flat I have Pinus edulis - Colorado Pinion, which have bright blue-gray juvenile foliage, and also seems winter hardy in zone 5b. During the last 2 winters coldest we have had is -17 F. (-27 C) which is typical low for our area. So far so good, but it is hard to say anything bonsai related about trees that young.
Last week saw a couple 8 foot tall in 40 gallon nursery cans P. bungeana at a Michigan nursery. The nursery was in a shady location, surrounded by tall trees, bark was mostly light gray, with only a hint of exfoliation. The trees were a couple hundred $$$ more than I thought fair for nursery stock, and that was with a 20% discount. The needles were thick, green, in bundles of 2 or 3 and some bundles of 4 and maybe 6+ inches long. The needles were more widely spaced on the first and second year growth than typical in a JBP or P. sylvestris. But that may be due to these trees being in a shady location. Over all, the P. strobus next to it seemed to have more bonsai potential. Overall impression was of a thick needled scotts pine or sparsely needled JBP, with weirdly smooth white-gray bark, not that of a relative of JWP which it botanically is in the 5 needle pine group. Odd. Really odd. My guess full sun would tighten up the needle spacing, but it probably really is a species best for full size, imperial sized bonsai, at least 4 feet tall and with thick trunks. The exfoliating bark could be pretty cool, but this won't be an easy species to get up to a useful size very quick. At least that is my guess, from what I've seen.
Just because I like the idea of exfoliating bark, I will keep an eye out for a low grafted bungeana ' Silver Ghost', thanks for the tip on that. Might use it in the landscape, though I can't help wanting to turn everything into bonsai. Thanks for the tip.