Will these wire scars go away? Liquidambar styraciflua and elm.

glacon

Yamadori
Messages
54
Reaction score
25
Location
Los Angeles, CA
USDA Zone
10b
Yesterday I purchased this charming liquidambar styraciflua root over rock bonsai from a reputable bonsai store in Los Angeles for a good bit of money. When I got it home I noticed there were some pretty large wire scars where the wire cut into the main branch. I thought, I wonder if the very similar elm I bought from them 3 weeks ago had the same problem. It was still wired so I carefully removed some of the wiring. It's pretty bad. The elm is at least a cork bark, so I imagine that may help? Thoughts? Both trees cost quite a pretty penny.
 

Attachments

  • 20210317_140940.jpg
    20210317_140940.jpg
    176.2 KB · Views: 241
  • 20210317_140946.jpg
    20210317_140946.jpg
    207.5 KB · Views: 184
  • 20210317_191319.jpg
    20210317_191319.jpg
    161.3 KB · Views: 238

Adair M

Pinus Envy
Messages
14,402
Reaction score
34,873
Location
NEGeorgia
USDA Zone
7a
Take all that wire off.

Wire on a deciduous only needs to stay on for a month to six weeks.
 

glacon

Yamadori
Messages
54
Reaction score
25
Location
Los Angeles, CA
USDA Zone
10b
Will do. It's the store that left the wire on. I'm very concerned about the scarring going away. It's pretty deep and these are pricey trees. If it'll go away I'm good. If not should I try and return them?
 

Potawatomi13

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
6,168
Reaction score
4,403
Location
Eugene, OR
USDA Zone
8
Please add location to profile. Will not go away. However in time providing rough bark develops much will become inconspicuous or invisible. Some wire valleys can fill back in IF bark under wire is not dead yet;). Personally enjoy watching scars heal or add character to trees. Also when trees in leaf much will be hidden.
 

Adair M

Pinus Envy
Messages
14,402
Reaction score
34,873
Location
NEGeorgia
USDA Zone
7a
The valleys will fill in. Over time, the scars will fade. Maybe not fully go away, but will not be as apparent. Wire scars are just part of the hobby. Sure, we try to minimize them, but they are pretty much unavoidable. Think of them like brush strokes on an oil painting.
 

glacon

Yamadori
Messages
54
Reaction score
25
Location
Los Angeles, CA
USDA Zone
10b
I appreciate the input. I was just so shocked at how deep some of them are. On the elm they seem to deform the branches. Not even sure I got good pics of those. The valleys have to go away completely. Just soften considerably. I think they were $1600 for both not including tax... so an investment from a high end bonsai nursery in LA. And they’re deciduous so I’ll be seeing the scars for some part of the year.
 

leatherback

The Treedeemer
Messages
13,937
Reaction score
26,871
Location
Northern Germany
USDA Zone
7
I would not accept these trees for that price with this sort of scarring. (Buuut I cannot see the whole tree which might very well be an exceptional tree) Then again.. I school at a nursery where deep wiremarks are a reason to regrow branches.

In the end the question: Will you for the next 5-10 years be annoyed with the marks. Then return the tree. I know I would (Well.. I would have checked the tree before buying, because I have had this experience once).
 

glacon

Yamadori
Messages
54
Reaction score
25
Location
Los Angeles, CA
USDA Zone
10b
If you bought it in person, and were able to look at the tree, I don't think you'd have any justification for taking it back.
In the case of the elm, with the wire on the tree the marks were not easily visible as they were covered. I am not experienced enough to know to look at it that closely before purchase (well I am now). With the other tree, it was a very rushed afair, it's a long story, but I was checking out with some others bonsai and they took a really long time finding that tree. I had not seen it yet, I was loading the others into my car, the broght it out, I had to rush to get back to work.
 

glacon

Yamadori
Messages
54
Reaction score
25
Location
Los Angeles, CA
USDA Zone
10b
FYI, these are full shots of the trees. The elm is still full wired in its picture. Looking at the photo of the elm, I'd have never known it would have those kinds of marks. Usually I can pickup when wires are cutting in. Now you can see them in all their glory
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20210310_174648_01.jpg
    IMG_20210310_174648_01.jpg
    271.1 KB · Views: 143
  • IMG_20210316_140912_01.jpg
    IMG_20210316_140912_01.jpg
    294 KB · Views: 163

leatherback

The Treedeemer
Messages
13,937
Reaction score
26,871
Location
Northern Germany
USDA Zone
7
full shots of the trees
From the pictures I get a feeling you might consider not going to that nursery again, but I do not live there so do nto know what is available.
The trees might have that value to you. I think however that better trees should be possible for that money.
 

glacon

Yamadori
Messages
54
Reaction score
25
Location
Los Angeles, CA
USDA Zone
10b
To be fair I have bought over 20 bonsai trees from them over the years. These are the only two I've had an issue with. I think the liquidambar was way over priced at $900. Since it was bought recently they probably would take that one back, especially since I have a history with them. The elm with the nastiest scars was bought three weeks ago, so less likely. I happen to really love that tree though. I just want to know if it's going to improve over time.

In LA there are not a lot of options for quality teees, and prices are high.

So back to my main question is, will these scars go away over time? Seems like from some of the posts they will.
 

glacon

Yamadori
Messages
54
Reaction score
25
Location
Los Angeles, CA
USDA Zone
10b
There are plenty or reputable bonsai artists that sell online, delivery is top-notch.
Any recommendations? This is Yamagachi Bonsai Nursery. I have bought around 26 bonsai and several regular trees and plants from them over the years. These two are the only ones I have had issues with. House of Bonsai I find to be of much lesser quality and much less variety.
 

hin175

Seedling
Messages
7
Reaction score
8
over 20-30 years, maybe...
I really don't like to comment on seller's prices, as each one need to live with all the costs associated with a shop, and that we (bonsaï enthusiasts) need professionals to provide us with many bonsai-related stuffs, in addition to trees themselves...

So I will only say I suggest you to try to take it back, as the time it would take the scars to disappear far exceeds the value the job they did could add to these trees. In brief, for that money, I would expect no wire scars on trees that size/shape.

If you keep them with the scars and except to have scar-less trees somewhere in the coming 10 years, you would need to cut these branches and regrow them. That's not what you're expecting in this price range...
 

glacon

Yamadori
Messages
54
Reaction score
25
Location
Los Angeles, CA
USDA Zone
10b
over 20-30 years, maybe...
I really don't like to comment on seller's prices, as each one need to live with all the costs associated with a shop, and that we (bonsaï enthusiasts) need professionals to provide us with many bonsai-related stuffs, in addition to trees themselves...

So I will only say I suggest you to try to take it back, as the time it would take the scars to disappear far exceeds the value the job they did could add to these trees. In brief, for that money, I would expect no wire scars on trees that size/shape.

If you keep them with the scars and except to have scar-less trees somewhere in the coming 10 years, you would need to cut these branches and regrow them. That's not what you're expecting in this price range...
Thank you for your input. This post covers everything I was wondering. I will bring them both back in a few hours. Hopefully the owner is around. Like I said the one I bought Tuesday, I think I can convince them to take back. The one bought at the end of February would be more difficult. I really love that one, but the wire scars are really awful on it.
 

Adair M

Pinus Envy
Messages
14,402
Reaction score
34,873
Location
NEGeorgia
USDA Zone
7a
First of all, deciduous trees should not be heavily wired. You really can’t move thick branches with wire. Thin, young branches, yes. The technique is the wire the thin, young branches, the ones that have not lignifed yet, and set them into position. Once they are lignified, remove the wire. That only takes a month to 6 weeks. Remove the wire before they start to scar up.

On your trees, they didn’t do that. Is it the end of the world? No. Those branches will heal to some extent, but the other thing I see is they are long and taperless. Which is a problem no matter that they have wire scars. What really needs to happen is some cut backs. Cut those branches back, and regrow them.

The “value” in those trees ARE NOT in the branches! The value is in there bases, the root over rock portions. The entire tops can be completely regrown in a year or so.

Stop stressing over the wire scars, and look to determine how the canopy can be, and should be restyled and regrown.

Don’t like the wire scars? No problem! Cut them off and grow new branches! Bjorn posted a video on YouTube recently where he showed a nice tree that had some wire scars, and he said the best remedy was just to cut them off and start over. Those are fast growing trees!
 
Top Bottom