Yellow needle tips -SW white pine

bonsairxmd

Shohin
Messages
476
Reaction score
46
Location
Oklahoma City (Zone 7a)
USDA Zone
7a
My Southwestern White Pine has yellow needle tips throughout the tree. (Same pine that caused such a ruckus in a recent thread ;))

I placed it in a wider pot with Boon's mix a few weeks ago. Did not mess with roots at all. It's in full sun. Fertilized with Miracid once. Watering when soil feels dry.

Any ideas? Thanks....
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    198.6 KB · Views: 48
  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    188.4 KB · Views: 44
I have no idea if that's normal for that species or not. It is an unusual species, so I doubt you'll get much response. I think you might do best by asking Brett.

About it being in Boon Mix...

You say you didn't touch the roots. If so, then what you have is afoot ball in nursery mix surrounded by Boon Mix. Boon Mix drains exceptionally fast. I don't know what soil the old rootball is. So what will happen when you water is the water will run right thru the Boon Zmix and out the bottom. Most likely, the old rootball isn't getting very wet.

You see, you have no roots in the boon mix. Roots won't grow out of the old rootball and into the Boon Mix on their own. Boon Mix is very open compared to most soil mixtures, and roots that are in tight rootball often won't move into the more open mix.

So, what you have to do to start using Boon Mix is a "half bare root" process. That is, bare root half the old root ball, and leave half untouched. This transitions the root system. Eventually, the half that gets bare rooted will find it really likes the Boon Mix, and will grow strong. Then, you bare root the other half.

The other thing you should do when potting is tease out 1/4 to 1/2 inch of feeder roots from the root ball. (Except the bottom. It should be flat, no roots extending down out if the rootball.). Make the sides fuzzy with feeder roots. Then use Boon mix and lightly chopstick it into place. The feeder roots should now have a start into the Boon Mix. Remember what I said how roots don't want to leave the old rootball to explore the new soil? Well, now they are in the new soil, so they'll start growing right on.

I bet if you pull the tree out of its soil, you'll find zero to very little roots growing out of the old soil into the new.

Boon mix is great stuff if used properly. But if used improperly, you may get poor results.
 
It's kinda late, based upon the look of the candles.

There's an old superstition in Japan: you can still repot JBP while the cherry trees are blooming. Since Brent says this can be treated like a JBP, if the Japanese cherry trees are still blooming where you are, you could try a repot. If they're done, don't.

If its too late, just be aware that when you water to make sure you give enough to soak the old rootball.
 
Thanks Adair. Great explanation. Can I go ahead and bare root half now?

Sheesh. This is precisely why I recommend slip potting only until the next repotting and root pruning opportunity (next winter). Plenty of my customers are beginners, and as soon as you start making false assumptions and recommendations for even light teasing, you end up with the poor beginner asking if he can bare root half the tree just before the heat of summer!

The tree is not in nursery mix, none of my trees are, they are in a bonsai mix of half bark and half perlite, the water drains right through, it is perfectly compatible with Boon's mix or any other suitable bonsai mix WITHOUT any root disturbance for the first season.

I spent a lot of time and thought on the instructions I send out with each shipment. It's frustrating when my customers try to keep out guessing me. I grew these babies from seed, I know the best general route for transition.

Brent
EvergreenGardenworks.com
 
Thanks, Brent, I have never purchased anything from you, so I don't know about your soil mix. I was assuming it was similar to Brussel's which is terrible.

Can you tell him if his needles look normal? I don't know anything about SW White Pine.
 
Brent's is one of 2-3 nurseries I trust buying big trees from online. His soil is great. I bought this shimpaku from Brent in late 2011, slip-potted it straight into this 24" mica pot, and still haven't needed to repot it.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    175.7 KB · Views: 40
Back
Top Bottom