Search results

For what it's worth, that's exactly how I interpreted post #55 in that thread...

Well, considering the average bickering going on in this thread and the average bickering going on in the other threads I guess the rating for this thread IS pretty unfair, at least in Bnut-standards...:)

I realize the poll isn't meant to be all scientific-y and I do think it's great to sometimes evaluate what it is we're doing, but it's kinda hard to quantify a qualitative question. It might be a good idea to tell the viewers why you (as in anyone) answered the poll the way you (as in anyone)...

The garden of their owners?

Good call, Vance! Seems to me like a pretty huge improvement!

I agree and I apologize. I realized me arguing what you said wasn't going to make any kind of difference since both of us can be pretty stubborn. I just wanted to end my part of the discussion (in a stupid way) but then I couldn't help myself so I posted some more (which was stupid). Anyway...

Will, I'm sorry to say that I think your arguments are so flawed nothing of what you say really makes sense to me. Here's why: The word "good". If I change my tone of voice the meaning changes. The word itself still means the same, but I communicate the opposite. The words themselves...

Now kiss and make up! :D

During my years in the "art society" I have barely heard "masterpieces" being discussed. I think the word belongs more in a craft setting, like cabinet making for instance that I've also studied. However, this might be due to difference in language. Sorry for this short and perhaps confusing...

There's clearly mycorrhiza in the first 3 pics. The "fuzzy" around the roots are hyphae that goes through the roots and into the soil. One can also see that there are short and "chubby" roots that resembles coral.

It's up!!!

Great, I didn't want to come across as if I actually knew anything :) Anyway, as far as I know you can actually see if there mycorrhiza on a pine because the root will be very well ramified. I've had it pointed out on a Pine bonsai by a professor of plant physiology and it doesn't look like...

Graydon, I really don't know enough about the whole thing so I can't really say that you're wrong. If the trees look healthy and all, that's all that matters. I hope I didn't come across as being agumentative. Regards Emil

I'm not sure I understand what you mean. Colonized by what? If it's mycel or hyphae you're talking about it's not so hard to explain. The fact that the soil is colonized by the stuff doesn't mean there's an actual symbiosis going on. Like I said, the fact that the soil is colonized by the...

What mycorrhiza basically does is to help the tree colonize a larger area thus giving the tree water and nutrients (wich there should be enough of in a pot) in exchange for carbohydrates. If the tree gets enough nitrogen (wich it should in a pot) the symbiosis stops or doesn't develop. After...

Mycorrhiza IS beneficial to decidious trees, but I have serious doubts how important it for trees in pots regardless if they're conifers or decidious. But then again, I can't really say I know anything about it.

They probably are, but just because there's mushrooms growing doesn't mean there's any kind of symbiosis going on. It's possible that the soil is full of mycel, but a tree that already has what it needs doesn't develop a symbiosis because it costs the tree nutrients to develop and sustain it.

That has to be one the most generous offers I have had the pleasure of recieving during my 3 years of e-bonsai. As much as I appreciate it I cannot possibly accept. Dale was kind enough to offer me the pot he won from the people's choice, and I feel that that's more than enough! Besides, I'm...

I have to agree with the statement above, and as most of you know I also have the same "elitist" approach when it comes to esthetics and art. However, just to play the devils advocate for a bit, when looking at the scores one can hardly argue that tradition or "rules" have played a major part in...

"Word!" as you Americans say.

What defines "masterpiece"?

Thanks to both of you!

Ok, here goes: Would you like to explain your own thoughts about a traditional vs. "contemporary" approach regarding the tree in question (in other words, what's are your personal preferences)? What defines a "contemporary" or modern pot in your eyes?

Nice, I also liked the fact that you posted your own thoughts regarding wich pot to use. Choosing pot is hard, wich this contest shows, and the more experienced members willing to elaborate on their choice the better for us ceramically/esthetically challenged...

Congrats Dale! To make the virts was a sheer pleasure. Evidently the pot selection was far more important than the virts themselves and I have to say that your pick was the best IMHO. And thanks for the pot, I'll remember it when I need another one :)