Does it matter what kind of water is used in humidity tray?

Messages
113
Reaction score
40
Location
Memphis, TN
USDA Zone
8a
Hubby and I have switched over to rain water for our delonix and for my Fukien for watering purposes - and they love it! I have also been using rain water in the humidity tray for my Fukien. Is this necessary or will tap water do? Will salt buildup be an issue with using tap water in humidity tray? It sounds like a silly question for me to ask, but I really don’t know the answer. If we could save rainwater for watering purposes that would be great, but if I need to continue using it in humidity tray, I will do so too.

Thank you!! ☺️
 

Bonsai Nut

Nuttier than your average Nut
Messages
12,420
Reaction score
27,868
Location
Charlotte area, North Carolina
USDA Zone
8a
Generally speaking, the idea of humidity tray is to create a "zone" of humid air around your tree. Because you are dealing with water vapor, it doesn't matter what water you use, because any minerals or salts will remain in the tray as the water evaporates. However... I am of the opinion that humidity trays don't really work, unless you are somehow enclosing the area to keep the water vapor in.
 

penumbra

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
9,381
Reaction score
15,852
Location
Front Royal, VA
USDA Zone
6
Humidity trays make a world of difference for me, but I do use large deep trays. I have 8 or 9 re blooming orchids in one tray and 3 indoor bonsai in another at this time. My trays are about 24 x 18 inches and 2 inches deep with fine aquarium gravel. I use well water which is very hard and causes minor calcium build up which I flush out 2 to 3 times a years.
I would not have much faith in small shallow trays unless you add water at least one a day and even then I am not sure.
 
Messages
113
Reaction score
40
Location
Memphis, TN
USDA Zone
8a
Generally speaking, the idea of humidity tray is to create a "zone" of humid air around your tree. Because you are dealing with water vapor, it doesn't matter what water you use, because any minerals or salts will remain in the tray as the water evaporates. However... I am of the opinion that humidity trays don't really work, unless you are somehow enclosing the area to keep the water vapor in.
Thank you!! ☺️ We will do a lot of research on a nice enclosure that we could make for them for he time that they are indoors! Thanks for sharing and the nice tip! ?
 
Messages
113
Reaction score
40
Location
Memphis, TN
USDA Zone
8a
Humidity trays make a world of difference for me, but I do use large deep trays. I have 8 or 9 re blooming orchids in one tray and 3 indoor bonsai in another at this time. My trays are about 24 x 18 inches and 2 inches deep with fine aquarium gravel. I use well water which is very hard and causes minor calcium build up which I flush out 2 to 3 times a years.
I would not have much faith in small shallow trays unless you add water at least one a day and even then I am not sure.
After reading what @Bonsai Nut shared about needing an enclosure, I can see how the deeper trays can be better than the shallow trays. Thanks for sharing your experience! ?
 

Wires_Guy_wires

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
6,411
Reaction score
10,637
Location
Netherlands
I also did some measurements on a wind free day.
There's a reason why the tree roots grow through the pot holes; it's damp enough.
But just for the first inch, after that the ambient air takes over.

Just like how a lit bunsen burner creates an umbrella, trays create a localized micro-dome of humid/saturated air. But a little airflow can ruin that effect for both the burner as well as the tray.
Check your lawn on a cold day, if it's misty outside, you'll see that there's a foot tall layer of somewhat stale air. It works in the same fashion when scaled down.
 
Top Bottom