Formal upright hinoki cypress 'Well's select'

Wood

Shohin
Messages
408
Reaction score
996
Location
Alexandria, VA
USDA Zone
7a
I started this tree during an intensive at Eisei-en. Formal uprights push my buttons in all the right ways, and I've got a small love affair with coastal redwoods and giant sequoias

Bjorn had mentioned a couple times in Q&As that he had bought an old field of balled and burlapped hinoki cypress. Most of those trees have been styled up and have left the garden so far. He even showed one at nationals this summer.

Before styling:
PXL_20220114_214219728.MP.jpg

Since I needed a project for the intensive, I decided to style one of the remaining hinokis. I really wanted to lean into the redwood look, and included a very dramatic and extended tachiagari. Bjorn had some fantastic styling suggestions: (1) instead of a typical bottom directional branch, use a mid-level point branch, (2) use a lot of negative space in the pot to indicate direction, (3) keep multiple apices

Cleaned out and bottom branches removed:
PXL_20220115_143728647.MP.jpg

All branches except the apex are wired and set:
PXL_20220115_230625276.MP.jpg

Fully styled:
PXL_20220116_181454385.MP.jpgPXL_20220116_185846490.MP.jpg

Gratuitous apices glamour shot:
PXL_20220116_181420104.MP.jpg

View attachment PXL_20220116_181601436.mp4

We chatted about pot selection and figured that it would take a really long time to find something that worked. I stopped by Owen Reich's the next day before driving home, and this was literally the first thing we saw at his place:
messages_0.jpeg

I'm leaving the tree at Eisei-en for the next three years during the intensive course. The biggest reason is that I live in an apartment with a tiny balcony and don't have the space to keep a tree like this yet. Until I move to a house with a proper yard, it's going to be getting the best care around
 

Bonsai Nut

Nuttier than your average Nut
Messages
12,471
Reaction score
28,093
Location
Charlotte area, North Carolina
USDA Zone
8a
I have mixed emotions about that second apex :)

Pros:
They occur in nature.
It may help give the tree a sense of scale and age.
Generates energy and conflict.

Cons:
Distracting. Draws the eye to the second apex and not the primary.
Disrupts the outline and balance of the design.

It breaks some big rules... which could be a good thing or not, depending :) It would certainly be the subject of conversation :) I would wimp out and reduce it to improve the flow of the tree... but it's a personal call.

alternate.jpg

This is just a suggestion based on what jumps out at me from a single photo. In general, I love hinokis, and I think this is a great tree!
 
Last edited:

BrierPatch

Mame
Messages
136
Reaction score
178
Location
Brier, WA.
USDA Zone
8b
That's a fantastic tree! I too love the Hinoki trees and have a few Wells Special's. It's also nice that the cultivar originated right here near me in NW Washington at Wells Nursery in Mount Vernon.
I watch for their specials they have and you can get them for a really fantastic price if anyone here in the PNW is interested.

I tend to agree with @Bonsai Nut on the second apex, but I'm not one to question Bjorn (or anyone) on his advise with my novice experience.
 

Wood

Shohin
Messages
408
Reaction score
996
Location
Alexandria, VA
USDA Zone
7a
The secondary/right and tertiary/middle apices were something we talked a lot about reducing in the future. At the moment I'm leaning into the weirdness of the tree and seeing how it ends up.

I kinda like the right one being taller than the middle apex. It feels like it tells the story of the tree better because the branch for the right apex is significantly thicker.

The weirdness is definitely amplified in photo. Seeing it in person doesn't feel as awkward as it looks in 2D. I hope the foliage fills in nicely and smooths out the oddness of it a bit
 

WNC Bonsai

Omono
Messages
1,899
Reaction score
2,159
Location
Western NC
USDA Zone
7b
From the perspective Bjorn looks lime the jolly green giant standing there next to the tree. No e tree but I would cut that second apex back as far as possible and still retain foliage making it a branch instead.
 
Messages
239
Reaction score
550
Location
Wisconsin
USDA Zone
5a
Totally understand the general consensus about an unusual feature such as a secondary apex like that not being entirely well received. Personally I think its quite charming, maybe there is something to be said about it being reigned in a bit, on the other hand it has an immense amount of visual interest.
 

Leprous Garden

Yamadori
Messages
98
Reaction score
67
Location
New England
USDA Zone
5b
I love the multi-apex look, makes the tree much more interesting to me. Very realistic! Bonsai is obsessed with making things look "natural" but then selects only the most manicured looking "natural" trees to mimic. Keep it weird!
 

Zerobear

Yamadori
Messages
99
Reaction score
101
Location
Central Mississippi
USDA Zone
8A
I started this tree during an intensive at Eisei-en. Formal uprights push my buttons in all the right ways, and I've got a small love affair with coastal redwoods and giant sequoias

Bjorn had mentioned a couple times in Q&As that he had bought an old field of balled and burlapped hinoki cypress. Most of those trees have been styled up and have left the garden so far. He even showed one at nationals this summer.

Before styling:
View attachment 416643

Since I needed a project for the intensive, I decided to style one of the remaining hinokis. I really wanted to lean into the redwood look, and included a very dramatic and extended tachiagari. Bjorn had some fantastic styling suggestions: (1) instead of a typical bottom directional branch, use a mid-level point branch, (2) use a lot of negative space in the pot to indicate direction, (3) keep multiple apices

Cleaned out and bottom branches removed:
View attachment 416644

All branches except the apex are wired and set:
View attachment 416645

Fully styled:
View attachment 416648View attachment 416651

Gratuitous apices glamour shot:
View attachment 416647

View attachment 416650

We chatted about pot selection and figured that it would take a really long time to find something that worked. I stopped by Owen Reich's the next day before driving home, and this was literally the first thing we saw at his place:
View attachment 416642

I'm leaving the tree at Eisei-en for the next three years during the intensive course. The biggest reason is that I live in an apartment with a tiny balcony and don't have the space to keep a tree like this yet. Until I move to a house with a proper yard, it's going to be getting the best care around
Great tree. I love it. I guess others had criticisms, but you won't hear any for me. I see many years of enjoyment for you and that makes me happy.
 

Wood

Shohin
Messages
408
Reaction score
996
Location
Alexandria, VA
USDA Zone
7a
Last weekend was my group's second session at Eisei-en, and I got a chance to work on this tree again. Bjorn put it in its first bonsai pot this spring, so it's out of potting soil and into aoki blend for now. He chose the pot from what he had in stock at the time. It's a pretty good fit, but I don't think it's the show pot for it

After:
PXL_20220625_193827129.MP.jpg

Before:
PXL_20220625_150943740.MP.jpg

360 video tour:
Gallery on Imgur
 

Wood

Shohin
Messages
408
Reaction score
996
Location
Alexandria, VA
USDA Zone
7a
Unfortunately, no. It died during the summer of 2023. During that winter, Bjorn had an insane cold snap and he had to prioritize saving the old trees. This one struggled to recover and eventually died
 
  • Sad
Reactions: R0b

The Barber

Shohin
Messages
284
Reaction score
946
Location
Kentucky
USDA Zone
6
Unfortunately, no. It died during the summer of 2023. During that winter, Bjorn had an insane cold snap and he had to prioritize saving the old trees. This one struggled to recover and eventually died
Maaan, that sucks. I have 6 of them I'm about to work on similar to it. I liked that one, what a bummer. Sucks Bjorn moved, reasonable drive for me to Nashville.
 

Wood

Shohin
Messages
408
Reaction score
996
Location
Alexandria, VA
USDA Zone
7a
I really appreciate it. God kick with yours and I hope to see how they come out!
 

Nybonsai12

Masterpiece
Messages
3,820
Reaction score
7,624
Location
NY
USDA Zone
7a
Bummer. It was a nice tree. Shit happens.
 
Top Bottom