I guess I'm more of a Japanese Traditionalist. Items that are displayed according to those guidelines are meant to evoke a scene that is unified. Whether shitakusa, figurines, suiseki, or scrolls are used they all work together to create the impression of a scene.Why Not it seems like everthing else in Bonsai (as far as the traditional guidelines are concerned) is fair game?
If it was presented as a traditional display--then it could be judged as such. It wasn't presented that way --therefore you can't judge it by traditional "rules".I guess I'm more of a Japanese Traditionalist. Items that are displayed according to those guidelines are meant to evoke a scene that is unified. Whether shitakusa, figurines, suiseki, or scrolls are used they all work together to create the impression of a scene.
In this case the dream catcher doesn't work for me. All I see is a nice bonsai and a random dream catcher that means nothing to the tree. It has no relation to the tree. With a traditional display all the objects displayed with the tree relate to it in some way.
Actually, I can judge it the way I want to. I'm the viewer . As stated in the post above my preference is for a coherent display, so naturally I would judge it that way.If it was presented as a traditional display--then it could be judged as such. It wasn't presented that way --therefore you can't judge it by traditional "rules".
I think its wrong to assume the Japanese think in a monolithic way about display. There are many schools of display in Japan as well.
You shouldn't have to judge by any criteria, you should be able to "know" and "feel". Then it works or it doesn't. It's not about what's in the display. Heck, it's not even about the tree. It's about how all of those things make you feel.I didn't meant to imply that you in particular were assuming anything Ryan. I just meant that in general we here in the USA naturally tend to look at the Japanese traditions in a monolithic fashion.
Of course you are free to view it as you wish. I agree with you--I dont think it works.
I still think though if you present it as a traditional tokonoma display--it has to judged by those criteria.
You can't really apply those same criteria to a display that was not presented as such.
Breaking the "rules" just for the sake of breaking them accomplishes nothing. The dream catcher breaks rules, but really adds nothing to the tree.I think the dream catcher makes the display one of the coolest I have seen. I like when someone thinks outside the box and breaks with tradition. Apparently others at the show must have liked it also since it won an award. Personally, I am not a big fan of all the rules and traditions in Bonsai. I wish more people would follow their own path instead of worrying what the Japanese traditionalists would think about it. When I see something different like this among all the "traditional Bonsai" it catches my eye. Just my 2¢.
Glad you liked it.To Me the Dream Catcher with the Bonsai evokes a very peaceful tranquil setting.
Non traditional to whom?
I am American Indian.
We are American not Japanese why wouldn't our traditions be a part of the display?
The Dream Catcher is made of wood, sinew, feathers.
It captures bad dreams in the web protecting us in our sleep.
Wood is the circle which is our home (planet).
Sinew is the animal including mankind (animals are our brothers and sisters).
Feathers is from the mighty birds (spirit guides in our dreams) who fly above us and build nests in the trees (also our eyes above ground).
Perhaps Americans need to remember the traditions of our Country and learn to incorporate our history as the Japanese have done with their displays (scrolls).
|Thread starter||Similar threads||Forum||Replies||Date|
|MABS April 13 - 14||Events, Exhibits & Outings||10|
|MABS April 7-9, 2017 Cromwell, CT||Events, Exhibits & Outings||10|
|MABS 2016 - April 15-17||Events, Exhibits & Outings||90|
|MABS Spring Festival 2014||Events, Exhibits & Outings||68|
|Y||I want to record MABS in HD for posterity||Events, Exhibits & Outings||3|