What would you do with this Calgary Carpet?

Atom#28

Chumono
Messages
557
Reaction score
1,273
Location
Eastern WA
USDA Zone
6b
"Put it in the ground and grow it out for a few years"

Yes. I agree. But I'm still left wondering: go for the obvious semi-cascade, or would you do something different? I have considered training the long whip into a new leader.... Virts are always helpful.



calgary carpet.jpg
 
Meanwhile, you could get some practice wiring and making foliage pads.

The problem I have with material like this is that thin peg coming rising up from the pot - the so-called 'trunk'. It is just boring and the hardest thing about the plant to change. It is probably too thick to bend much, so what is there to do with it? What would make it interesting or how could it be effectively hidden?

Just because it has one long branch, why does it have to be a cascade? Suppose you removed it entirely or made a short jin of it? What is left is possibly an interesting, though maybe unconventional, little tree - do you think? I'm not so sure either but it interests me more than another routine cascade.

So what I might do, were it mine, is to wire the big branch and bend/twist it up to grow more trunk over the coming years - make something that might be interesting. I would stick the wire in the pot at the base of the trunk and wrap the trunk tightly to serve as the anchor. Prospectively I will let this wire bite in to make a looping live vein. So I will need to make the loops of wire irregular so it won't be a barber pole. Okay, future direction set. Now back to that prospectively interesting little tree. Lets see what I can make with that (cover the heavy left trunk that is now doing some dance upward with something so I can see this other stuff clearly). A little wire, a little trimming to make pads and position them. Then ponder over the winter why what I tried to do didn't work or why did it come out some much more interesting that I thought it could be.

Maybe something interesting comes of this. Maybe not. The thing is that bonsai is not permanent, especially at this stage of the game. Challenge yourself to learn how to do styling and keeping it vigorously growing. If at some point you are just exhausted by it, put it on the shelf and go do something else. When you come back it will have changed. You can follow through on how the long branch wired to be trunk is coming along. Are you going to remove the wire or just let it bite in? Do you see exciting possibilities for this further into the future? Maybe it bores you and you like the little tree on the right idea. Then again, maybe some new image is coming to your mind by then. This, IMHO, is the adventure.

Enjoy.
 
Wow, thank you very much! Possibly the best response I could have hoped for! I would like to learn more about how to set up for the future live vein: does the live vein develop where the wire bites the trunk? do you have any links that might help me understand the mechanics of this process?
 
The stem a wire is wrapped around gets thicker each year and eventually starts to engulf the wire. This is what we call 'biting in'. It will take a few years to happen. Generally we don't like it to because it leaves 'wire scars' in the stem after we've taken the wire off. This is because the wire causes the cambium to get 'squeezed' to the point it dies immediately beneath the wire. The stem not only continues to grow where the wire isn't, it actually thickens faster than normal. If the wire is removed, the cambium will eventually be revived but the 'wire scar' is very difficult to remove because of this.

In your case you want this. To make it permanent, you will actually cut away some tissue at the edge of the wire or after having removed the wire. You will do this light cutting for a year or two (maybe exaggerating it in some places for a few years) keeping the wood exposed more or less along this line where the wire was. Over the years, new wood will only be added under the live vein and will produce a trunk that looks something like this juniper's trunk, after many years. 73001139_10214178634131913_6285898548542177280_o.jpg

I've mentioned the possibility of leaving the wire on and letting it get engulfed. This is a way to get a thicker trunk in a shorter time than normally happens. Some growers do this to make low cost Japanese black pines. It works, but invariably leaves visible evidence of where the wire was = sad. You could do this as well. At any rate, you don't need to decide for several years yet.

Look in the BNut Resources. There are several articles related to junipers.
 
Update: I decided to go with cascade in first styling, late October 2019. Tree continued to grow without issue, though it is currently unkempt and ready for new wiring this season. Here it is today. Updates to come. Looking for a little cascade pot for spring 2022


035CF7B1-7F67-4CAA-BC66-7B5D441114D6.jpegEF4214BC-9233-469C-AA1D-0220053A1CF4.jpeg
F64EF3C9-5092-49DE-B012-2425B22830B0.jpeg




5F5F6FE9-BE3C-4CBF-9DC8-00AE7055E6BC.jpeg
 
Wow, a lot of great development in a short period of time!

Juniper cascades can be a little tricky, because it is hard to keep the descending branch strong enough. As you continue to develop the tree, make sure to keep the upper branches restrained, while continuing to build foliage pads on the descending branch. It all depends on how far you want to go with that branch. As a semi-cascade it's not as important as if you were planning a more dramatic cascade.

Also, your styling of the current upper branch looks a little "loopy" instead of a series of sharp angles. You don't want your final tree looking like a clean spiral or a curlicue - because a tree would not tend to grow like that in nature.
 
the current upper branch looks a little "loopy"
I appreciate that feedback! Yeah, the apex is a full on spiral right now. First styling, I was having trouble getting that branch to cooperate in the other direction and worried I was going to kill it. BUT, I think I have a solution. Next wiring, I plan to pull that loop leftward, and tilt the apex further toward the viewer (assuming the front remains as seen in pic #1 above) . UNloop it. Maybe I can impart some destructive "randomness of nature" character to that section over time? I want to push the overall foliar mass further left as well, and get the right side foliage a lil tighter to the trunk. I'll try a vert...
 
Maybe 0.5 to 0.75 inch. It’s about as thick as my thumb
Thanks for your response, my concern is in line with the comments made by Osoyoung and Potawatomi. The trunk currently is thin enough to wire, bend and then would be best grown out before styling and constant pruning. Just for fun, see if you can acquire another similar size juniper whip and try the opposite method of development. Bonsai are much more believable when the trunk gives them a sense of reasonable proportion.
 
Wired. My technique while drinking is highly questionable….

72111CC1-7B6E-4BEC-9B35-A7309DF7F29A.jpeg
 
Back
Top Bottom