Yet Another Tree ID

JoeR

Masterpiece
Messages
4,049
Reaction score
3,593
Location
Sandhills of North Carolina
USDA Zone
8a
This is a stump that I chopped and collected this winter. I didn't know what it was but it has great bark for being so small so I figured why not. I started sawing it down to the lowest branch on the tree only to find out that the branch was dead. It was already too late so I finished the deed. It was chopped to nothing but a stump.


Come this spring, I notice it was (surprisingly) pushing out a few buds so I dug it up. Yet another complication, it is a shoot off a root from a larger tree. Some roots but not much.

Despite all this, it survived and is vigorous! The only issue is that the leaves are huge. I think they will reduce but I don't know if It will reduce enough to match the trunk size of this one. I cut one (I saw this done on a cherry in "The Bonsai Art of Japan") and it looks fine, it browned just a tiny bit on the edge but it's not noticeable.

I think its some sort of oak. I know oaks hybridize so it's difficult to identify them, but if anyone can tell me that it is an oak, and if so what kind of oak it is and if the leaves reduce that would be awesome.

Pictures:0530151937.jpg 0530151938.jpg


Joe
 
I have to guesses ... Quercus nigra (water oak) , or Quercus marilandica (blackjack oak)
 
Probably the former due to the bark color but I can assure you most oak species are tough in terms of leaf reduction
 
It is not a water oak, however I have been wanting to collect one of those.

The second one (blackjack) seems pretty close to what I have. I can't tell for sure though.
 
I think it IS a water oak. You will not be able to reduce leaf size.
 
I think it IS a water oak. You will not be able to reduce leaf size.
The only reason I don't think it is is because the leaves of the water oak are much smaller than mine. I will post a pic of the new leaves coming out and I will measure the leaf size to see if that helps.
 
Leaves of seedling trees or new sprouts are often larger thn commonly seen on mature trees. However, the shape here is distinctive.
 
Back
Top Bottom